Le Duff Michel J, Takamura Kohtaroh B, Amstutz Harlan C
Joint Replacement Institute at Saint Vincent Medical Center, Los Angeles, California 90057, USA.
Bull NYU Hosp Jt Dis. 2011;69 Suppl 1:S36-41.
A retrospective analysis of 1000 hips in 838 patients was conducted to determine the efficacy of alterations made throughout the series to the prophylactic protocol used to minimize the incidence of heterotopic ossification (HO) after hip resurfacing.
Four groups were determined following the initiation of these changes. Initially, the patients received indomethacin and 1000 milliliters of both saline and duobiotic (group 1). In group 2, a single pre-operative 700 cGy radiotherapy session was added for males undergoing one-stage bilateral procedures or the second stage of a two-stage procedure when HO had formed on the first hip. In group 3, the volume of saline used to clean the wound after implantation was increased from 1000 to 2000 milliliters, while the 1000 milliliters of duobiotic remained throughout the series. Finally, the use of a plastic drape was added to collect bone debris during the reaming of the femoral head in group 4. Chi-square analyses were conducted between groups to identify significant decreases in the prevalence of HO.
Group 3 showed a reduction in incidence of all HO grades combined, and severe HO only compared with group 2 (p = 0.003 and p = 0.007, respectively). A decrease in severe HO incidence was observed between group 1 and group 2 in males who underwent bilateral surgery (p = 0.048). In addition, there was a significant decrease in the incidence of both all HO grades (p = 0.0001) and severe HO (p = 0.029) between groups 1 and 4. In contrast to most studies that have assessed the individual effect of prophylactic methods in a single protocol, the present study confirmed the effectiveness of combining indomethacin and radiation therapy in high-risk patients, as well as copious pulse lavage of the wound in reducing the incidence of HO. The use of the plastic drape did not confer any additional gain.
对838例患者的1000个髋关节进行回顾性分析,以确定在整个系列中对预防性方案所做的改变对减少髋关节表面置换术后异位骨化(HO)发生率的效果。
在这些改变开始后确定了四组。最初,患者接受吲哚美辛以及1000毫升生理盐水和双抗生素(第1组)。在第2组中,对于接受一期双侧手术的男性或当第一侧髋关节已形成HO时接受二期手术的男性,术前增加一次700 cGy放疗。在第3组中,植入后用于清洗伤口的生理盐水用量从1000毫升增加到2000毫升,而整个系列中双抗生素用量保持1000毫升。最后,在第4组中,在股骨头扩髓时增加使用塑料单来收集骨碎屑。对组间进行卡方分析以确定HO发生率的显著降低。
与第2组相比,第3组所有HO分级合并发生率以及仅重度HO发生率均降低(分别为p = 0.003和p = 0.007)。在接受双侧手术的男性中,第1组和第2组之间重度HO发生率降低(p = 0.048)。此外,第1组和第4组之间所有HO分级发生率(p = 0.0001)和重度HO发生率(p = 0.029)均显著降低。与大多数评估单一方案中预防性方法个体效果的研究不同,本研究证实了吲哚美辛与放疗联合用于高危患者以及大量脉冲冲洗伤口在降低HO发生率方面的有效性。使用塑料单未带来任何额外益处。