Ulaş Umit Hıdır, McNeeley Kevin, Zhang Di, Chelimsky Gisela, Chelimsky Thomas
Neurological Institute, University Hospitals Case Medical Center, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH, USA.
Anadolu Kardiyol Derg. 2011 Dec;11(8):674-7. doi: 10.5152/akd.2011.187. Epub 2011 Oct 28.
The aim of this study was to determine whether patients who faint earlier in the course of a tilt table study represent a separate population with a poorer prognosis or different pathophysiology. We analyzed differences across patients with different syncopal times on the tilt-table study to answer this question.
This was a retrospective, approved, chart review. From our database of over 6000 patients, we identified 1222 patients with syncope. After excluding patients with orthostatic hypotension, postural tachycardia syndrome and diabetes, we were left with 131 patients with pure reflex syncope. We divided fainters into an early (<20 minutes) and late (>20 minutes) faint times. Along with the tilt table test all patients underwent heart rate response for deep breathing, Valsalva maneuver and quantitative sudomotor axon reflex tests.
By 10 minutes in the tilt study, only 18% of subjects had fainted, 65% by 20 minutes, 92% by 30 minutes and 96% by 35 minutes. Age was evenly distributed across all syncopal times. Neither the 14 abnormal cardiac responses to deep breathing nor the 20 abnormal Valsalva maneuvers, nor the 28 abnormal axon reflex responses clustered with an early or late faint time.
A 10-minute tilt will miss 82% of syncopal episodes, while a 30- minute tilt increases the yield 10-fold, missing only 8%. Patients with early faint times did not differ from patients with late fainting times with regard to age or autonomic test abnormalities. Timing of syncope during the tilt table test does not associated with more severe dysautonomia. A prospective study is needed to confirm these observations.
本研究旨在确定在倾斜试验过程中较早晕厥的患者是否代表预后较差或病理生理不同的独立人群。我们分析了倾斜试验中不同晕厥时间患者之间的差异,以回答这个问题。
这是一项经过批准的回顾性病历审查。从我们超过6000例患者的数据库中,我们识别出1222例晕厥患者。在排除体位性低血压、体位性心动过速综合征和糖尿病患者后,我们剩下131例单纯反射性晕厥患者。我们将晕厥患者分为早期(<20分钟)和晚期(>20分钟)晕厥时间组。除倾斜试验外,所有患者均接受了深呼吸、瓦尔萨尔瓦动作时的心率反应以及定量汗腺轴突反射试验。
在倾斜试验的10分钟时,只有18%的受试者晕厥,20分钟时为65%,30分钟时为92%,35分钟时为96%。年龄在所有晕厥时间组中分布均匀。14例深呼吸时的异常心脏反应、20例瓦尔萨尔瓦动作异常以及28例轴突反射异常反应均未在早期或晚期晕厥时间组中聚集。
10分钟的倾斜试验会遗漏82%的晕厥发作,而30分钟的倾斜试验可使检出率提高10倍,仅遗漏8%。早期晕厥患者与晚期晕厥患者在年龄或自主神经测试异常方面没有差异。倾斜试验期间晕厥的时间与更严重的自主神经功能障碍无关。需要进行前瞻性研究来证实这些观察结果。