Leitgeb Norbert, Niedermayr Florian, Loos Gerhart, Neubauer Robert
Institute of Health Care Engineering with European Notified Body of Medical Devices, Graz University of Technology, Graz, Austria.
Wien Med Wochenschr. 2011 Dec;161(23-24):571-7. doi: 10.1007/s10354-011-0038-z. Epub 2011 Nov 8.
In view of reported fatalities there are still controversial discussions on whether electronic stun law enforcement weapons can cause cardiac fibrillation. Experimental data are contradictory. Simplified theoretical estimations led to a negligible low risk of 8.10(-7). With a detailed numerical-anatomical model of an adult man (NORMAN) cardiac exposure to Taser X26 high-tension pulses was quantitatively assessed and the fibrillation risk estimated by accounting for its dependence on excited volume based on 3D cardiac exposure patterns. For distance mode and worst case dart hits it could be demonstrated that cardiac exposure can reach the 30% fibrillation risk level. Risk reduces considerably if direct current flow across the heart is prevented. The overall fibrillation risk of Taser application is further reduced by the limited probability of critical hits. However, in agreement with experimental findings it is demonstrated that cardiac fibrillation risk of Taser X26 dart mode application is small, however, not negligible.
鉴于有死亡报告,关于电子眩晕执法武器是否会导致心脏纤颤仍存在争议性讨论。实验数据相互矛盾。简化的理论估计得出极低的可忽略风险,为8×10⁻⁷ 。通过一个成年男性的详细数字解剖模型(NORMAN),对心脏暴露于泰瑟X26高压脉冲的情况进行了定量评估,并根据基于3D心脏暴露模式的兴奋体积依赖性来估计纤颤风险。对于距离模式和最坏情况的飞镖命中情况,可以证明心脏暴露可达到30%的纤颤风险水平。如果防止直流电通过心脏,风险会大幅降低。泰瑟枪应用的总体纤颤风险因关键命中的有限概率而进一步降低。然而,与实验结果一致,证明泰瑟X26飞镖模式应用的心脏纤颤风险较小,但并非可忽略不计。