Department of Psychiatry, University of California Davis, Sacramento, California, USA.
Telemed J E Health. 2012 Jan-Feb;18(1):74-7. doi: 10.1089/tmj.2011.0086. Epub 2011 Nov 15.
Store-and-forward telepsychiatry, or asynchronous telepsychiatry (ATP), which allows clinical data, including video to be collected to be reviewed at a later time by a specialist, has been described as a feasible alternative to real-time telepsychiatry, or synchronous telepsychiatry (STP), as a consultation model for primary care. In theory, ATP should be economically more cost-effective than STP due to the increased flexibility of patient data collection and the substitution of the time of specialists with that of lower-cost providers. The aim of this study was to conduct a retrospective cost-analysis comparing ATP with STP and traditional in-person psychiatric consultations in the primary care setting. One hundred and twenty five ATP consultations were performed and fixed and marginal costs were calculated for each model using inputs such as equipment costs, time spent by providers and support staff, and hourly salaries. The fixed costs were $7,000 and $20,000 for ATP and STP and marginal costs were $68.18, $107.50, and $96.36, respectively, for the three groups. STP was the most expensive of the three types of consultations. ATP became the most cost-effective of the three models beyond 249 consultations. The marginal cost savings of ATP were due to substitution of low-cost providers for specialists. ATP represents a potential disruptive healthcare process that could allow more affordable care to be delivered to a larger population of patients. A full accounting of ATP's efficiency will require further studies, including prospective cost-benefit analyses from the perspectives of the patient, provider, and society.
存储转发式远程精神病学,或异步远程精神病学(ATP),允许收集临床数据,包括视频,以供专家在以后的时间进行审查,它被描述为实时远程精神病学(STP)或同步远程精神病学(STP)的可行替代方案,作为初级保健的咨询模式。从理论上讲,由于患者数据收集的灵活性增加以及用低成本提供者代替专家的时间,ATP 应该比 STP 在经济上更具成本效益。本研究的目的是进行回顾性成本分析,比较 ATP 与 STP 和传统的面对面精神病学咨询在初级保健环境中的成本。进行了 125 次 ATP 咨询,并为每种模型计算了固定和边际成本,使用设备成本、提供者和支持人员花费的时间以及每小时工资等投入。ATP 和 STP 的固定成本分别为 7000 美元和 20000 美元,而三组的边际成本分别为 68.18 美元、107.50 美元和 96.36 美元。STP 是三种咨询方式中最昂贵的。ATP 的边际成本节约是由于用低成本提供者替代了专家。ATP 代表了一种潜在的颠覆性医疗保健流程,可以为更多的患者群体提供更负担得起的护理。要充分了解 ATP 的效率,还需要进一步研究,包括从患者、提供者和社会的角度进行前瞻性成本效益分析。