University of Iowa Carver College of Medicine, Iowa City, IA, USA.
J Hosp Med. 2012 Mar;7(3):218-23. doi: 10.1002/jhm.975. Epub 2011 Nov 15.
Hospice is a service that patients, families, and physicians find beneficial, yet a majority of patients die without receiving hospice care. Little is known about how many hospitalized patients are hospice eligible at the time of hospitalization.
Retrospective chart review was used to examine all adult deaths (n = 688) at a tertiary care center during 2009. Charts were selected for full review if the death was nontraumatic and the patient had a hospital admission within 12 months of the terminal admission. The charts were examined for hospice eligibility based on medical criteria, evidence of a hospice discussion, and hospice enrollment.
Two hundred nine patients had an admission in the year preceding the terminal admission and a nontraumatic death. Sixty percent were hospice eligible during the penultimate admission. Hospice discussions were documented in 14% of the hospice-eligible patients. Patients who were hospice eligible had more subspecialty consults on the penultimate admission compared to those not hospice eligible (P = 0.016), as well as more overall hospitalizations in the 12 months preceding their terminal admission (P = 0.0003), and fewer days between their penultimate admission and death (P = 0.001).
The majority of terminally ill inpatients did not have a documented discussion of hospice with their care provider. Educating physicians to recognize the stepwise decline of most illnesses and hospice admission criteria will facilitate a more informed decision-making process for patients and their families. A consistent commitment to offer hospice earlier than the terminal admission would increase access to community or home-based care, potentially increasing quality of life.
缓和医疗是一种患者、家属和医生都认为有益的服务,但大多数患者在临终前没有接受缓和医疗。目前尚不清楚有多少住院患者在住院时符合缓和医疗的条件。
采用回顾性病历审查的方法,对 2009 年在一家三级医疗中心死亡的所有成年患者(n=688)进行了研究。如果死亡是非创伤性的,且患者在终末期入院前 12 个月内有住院记录,则选择这些患者的病历进行全面审查。根据医疗标准、缓和医疗讨论的证据和缓和医疗的登记情况,对病历进行了缓和医疗资格审查。
209 例患者在终末期入院前一年有过住院记录且死亡是非创伤性的。60%的患者在次终末期入院时符合缓和医疗的条件。在符合缓和医疗条件的患者中,有 14%的患者记录了缓和医疗讨论。与不符合缓和医疗条件的患者相比,符合缓和医疗条件的患者在次终末期入院时接受了更多的专科会诊(P=0.016),在终末期入院前的 12 个月内接受了更多的住院治疗(P=0.0003),并且从次终末期入院到死亡的天数更少(P=0.001)。
大多数临终住院患者的护理提供者没有记录与他们讨论过缓和医疗。教育医生认识到大多数疾病的逐步恶化和缓和医疗入院标准,将有助于患者及其家属做出更明智的决策。始终承诺在终末期入院前更早地提供缓和医疗服务,将增加获得社区或家庭为基础的护理的机会,从而有可能提高生活质量。