Ishiwatari Yoko, Muramoto Toshiaki
Graduate School of Information Sciences, Tohoku University, Aramaki Aoba-ku, Sendai 980-8579, Japan.
Shinrigaku Kenkyu. 2011 Oct;82(4):354-61. doi: 10.4992/jjpsy.82.354.
Children's macroprocessing skills for comprehension of expository text were investigated by focusing on the additive effect of such skills on the readers' working memory (WM) capacity. In Experiment 1, 181 fourth and fifth graders read topic explicit and implicit expository texts. After reading each text, they were asked to recall the topic and other information in the text. In Experiment 2, 617 fourth and fifth graders were randomly assigned to one of three conditions: instructional conditions of either being encouraged to grasp the topic of the text or being encouraged to remember details of the text, or a control condition. Then they read and recalled expository texts. As a whole, children with high scores for macroprocessing skills significantly outperformed children with low scores on the recall tasks. These effects remained after controlling for WM capacity, suggesting that the acquisition of macroprocessing skills may benefit children's reading over and above the effect of differences in their WM capacity. However, the results also indicated that the effects of these skills depended on the text and instructional conditions.
通过关注儿童宏观加工技能对读者工作记忆(WM)容量的累加效应,研究了儿童理解说明文文本的宏观加工技能。在实验1中,181名四年级和五年级学生阅读了主题明确和隐含的说明文文本。阅读每篇文本后,要求他们回忆文本的主题和其他信息。在实验2中,617名四年级和五年级学生被随机分配到三种条件之一:鼓励把握文本主题的教学条件、鼓励记住文本细节的教学条件或控制条件。然后他们阅读并回忆说明文文本。总体而言,宏观加工技能得分高的儿童在回忆任务上的表现显著优于得分低的儿童。在控制了工作记忆容量后,这些效应仍然存在,这表明宏观加工技能的习得可能会在儿童工作记忆容量差异的影响之上,使他们的阅读受益。然而,结果也表明,这些技能的效果取决于文本和教学条件。