Celentano D D, Stewart W F, Linet M S
Division of Behavioral Sciences and Health Education, School of Hygiene and Public Health, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21205.
J Clin Epidemiol. 1990;43(9):983-94. doi: 10.1016/0895-4356(90)90082-z.
Efforts to develop clinically useful headache classification schemes have generally focused on linking specific symptom groupings with specific headache subtypes. An alternative conceptual approach, the "severity model" of headache, considers a continuum of headache ranging from mild to severe forms with specific headache subtypes distinguished by level of severity rather than unique constellations of symptoms. A population-based telephone interview was carried out among 10,169 subjects aged 12-29 to estimate the prevalence of serious headaches and better characterize symptoms that accompany headache attacks. In an analysis of frequency of occurrence, pain and duration of recent (within 4 weeks prior to interview) headache attacks, the data revealed that common symptoms (such as forehead pain and pain in the back of the head, neck and shoulders) were reported frequently, but headaches with these symptoms were generally characterized by low levels of pain and short duration. Although not an original study objective, the data were analyzed to determine whether distinct symptom constellations could be identified or whether symptoms overlapped between headache types. Symptoms of migraine were frequently experienced concomitant with tension-type symptoms; the resultant headaches were usually characterized as moderate in intensity. In contrast, symptoms usually associated with migraine in the absence of concomitant tension-type symptoms were infrequently experienced, but resulted in headaches causing the greatest disability. The data provide some support for the severity model of headache.
开发临床上有用的头痛分类方案的努力通常集中在将特定的症状组合与特定的头痛亚型联系起来。一种替代的概念方法,即头痛的“严重程度模型”,考虑了从轻度到重度形式的头痛连续体,特定的头痛亚型由严重程度而非独特的症状组合来区分。对10169名年龄在12 - 29岁的受试者进行了基于人群的电话访谈,以估计严重头痛的患病率,并更好地描述头痛发作时伴随的症状。在对近期(访谈前4周内)头痛发作的发生频率、疼痛程度和持续时间的分析中,数据显示常见症状(如前额疼痛以及头后部、颈部和肩部疼痛)报告频繁,但伴有这些症状的头痛通常疼痛程度较低且持续时间较短。尽管这不是最初的研究目标,但对数据进行了分析,以确定是否可以识别出不同的症状组合,或者头痛类型之间的症状是否重叠。偏头痛症状经常与紧张型症状同时出现;由此产生的头痛通常强度为中度。相比之下,在没有伴随紧张型症状的情况下通常与偏头痛相关的症状很少出现,但会导致造成最大残疾的头痛。这些数据为头痛的严重程度模型提供了一些支持。