Civil and Environmental Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2011 Dec 20;108(51):20428-33. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1012253108. Epub 2011 Dec 5.
Capturing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere ("air capture") in an industrial process has been proposed as an option for stabilizing global CO(2) concentrations. Published analyses suggest these air capture systems may cost a few hundred dollars per tonne of CO(2), making it cost competitive with mainstream CO(2) mitigation options like renewable energy, nuclear power, and carbon dioxide capture and storage from large CO(2) emitting point sources. We investigate the thermodynamic efficiencies of commercial separation systems as well as trace gas removal systems to better understand and constrain the energy requirements and costs of these air capture systems. Our empirical analyses of operating commercial processes suggest that the energetic and financial costs of capturing CO(2) from the air are likely to have been underestimated. Specifically, our analysis of existing gas separation systems suggests that, unless air capture significantly outperforms these systems, it is likely to require more than 400 kJ of work per mole of CO(2), requiring it to be powered by CO(2)-neutral power sources in order to be CO(2) negative. We estimate that total system costs of an air capture system will be on the order of $1,000 per tonne of CO(2), based on experience with as-built large-scale trace gas removal systems.
从大气中捕获二氧化碳(“空气捕获”)已被提议作为稳定全球 CO(2)浓度的一种选择。已公布的分析表明,这些空气捕获系统的成本可能为每吨 CO(2)几百美元,使其与主流 CO(2)减排选项(如可再生能源、核能以及从大型 CO(2)排放点源捕获和储存 CO(2))具有成本竞争力。我们研究了商业分离系统以及痕量气体去除系统的热力学效率,以更好地了解和限制这些空气捕获系统的能源需求和成本。我们对现有商业工艺的实证分析表明,从空气中捕获 CO(2)的能源和财务成本可能被低估了。具体来说,我们对现有气体分离系统的分析表明,除非空气捕获显著优于这些系统,否则它可能需要每摩尔 CO(2)超过 400 kJ 的功,这就要求它由 CO(2)中性的电源供电,才能实现 CO(2)负排放。根据大型痕量气体去除系统的实际经验,我们估计空气捕获系统的总系统成本将达到每吨 CO(2)约 1000 美元。