Nsagha Dickson Shey, Bamgboye Elijah Afolabi, Assob Jules Clement Nguedia, Njunda Anna Longdoh, Kamga Henri Lucien Foumou, Zoung-Kanyi Bissek Anne-Cécile, Tabah Earnest Nji, Oyediran Alain Bankole O O, Njamnshi Alfred Kongnyu
Department of Public Health and Hygiene, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Buea, Buea, Cameroon.
Pan Afr Med J. 2011;9:4. doi: 10.4314/pamj.v9i1.71176. Epub 2011 May 17.
Leprosy is caused by Mycobacterium leprae and manifests as damage to the skin and peripheral nerves. The disease is dreaded because it causes deformities, blindness and disfigurement. Worldwide, 2 million people are estimated to be disabled by leprosy. Multidrug therapy is highly effective in curing leprosy, but treating the nerve damage is much more difficult. The World Health Assembly targeted to eliminate leprosy as a public health problem from the world by 2000. The objective of the review was to assess the successes of the leprosy elimination strategy, elimination hurdles and the way forward for leprosy eradication.
A structured search was used to identify publications on the elimination strategy. The keywords used were leprosy, elimination and 2000. To identify potential publications, we included papers on leprosy elimination monitoring, special action projects for the elimination of leprosy, modified leprosy elimination campaigns, and the Global Alliance to eliminate leprosy from the following principal data bases: Cochrane data base of systematic reviews, PubMed, Medline, EMBASE, and the Leprosy data base. We also scanned reference lists for important citations. Key leprosy journals including WHO publications were also reviewed.
The search identified 63 journal publications on leprosy-related terms that included a form of elimination of which 19 comprehensively tackled the keywords including a book on leprosy elimination. In 1991, the 44th World Health Assembly called for the elimination of leprosy as a public health problem in the world by 2000. Elimination was defined as less than one case of leprosy per 10000-population. Elimination has been made possible by a confluence of several orders of opportunities: the scientific (the natural history of leprosy at the present state of knowledge), technological (multi-drug therapy and the blister pack); political (commitment of governments) and financial (support from NGOs for example the Nippon Foundation that supplies free multi-drug therapy) opportunities. Elimination created the unrealistic expectation that the leprosy problem could be solved by 2000. First, the elimination goal was not feasible in several areas which had high incidence of leprosy. Even if elimination was to be attained, significant numbers of new cases of leprosy would continue to occur and many people with physical imperfections, severe psychological, economic and social problems caused by leprosy would need continuous assistance. Extra-human reservoirs of Mycobacterium leprae, the relationship between leprosy and poverty, prevention of disabilities, lack of a reliable laboratory test to detect subclinical infection and a vaccine are also challenging issues.
The evidence base available to inform on leprosy elimination is highly positive with the availability of multi-drug therapy blister packs. There are concerns that leprosy was not the right disease to be targeted for elimination as there are no reliable diagnostic tests to detect subclinical infection including the lack of a vaccine, extra-human reservoirs (monkeys and armadillos), increase in the burden of child cases, no good epidemiological indicator as prevalence instead of incidence is used to measure elimination. Multi-drug therapy treats leprosy very well but there is no proof that it concurrently interrupts transmission. The high social stigma, prevention of disabilities, and the relationship between leprosy and poverty are still major concerns.
麻风病由麻风分枝杆菌引起,表现为皮肤和周围神经受损。这种疾病令人恐惧,因为它会导致畸形、失明和毁容。据估计,全球有200万人因麻风病而致残。多药疗法在治愈麻风病方面非常有效,但治疗神经损伤则困难得多。世界卫生大会的目标是到2000年在全球消除作为公共卫生问题的麻风病。本综述的目的是评估消除麻风病战略的成效、消除障碍以及根除麻风病的未来方向。
采用结构化检索来识别关于消除战略的出版物。使用的关键词是麻风病、消除和2000年。为识别潜在出版物,我们纳入了来自以下主要数据库的关于麻风病消除监测、消除麻风病特别行动项目、改良麻风病消除运动以及全球消除麻风病联盟的论文:Cochrane系统评价数据库、PubMed、Medline、EMBASE和麻风病数据库。我们还浏览参考文献列表以获取重要引文。还查阅了包括世卫组织出版物在内的主要麻风病期刊。
检索共识别出63篇关于麻风病相关术语的期刊出版物,其中包括一种消除形式,其中19篇全面涉及了关键词,包括一本关于麻风病消除的书籍。1991年,第44届世界卫生大会呼吁到2000年在全球消除作为公共卫生问题的麻风病。消除的定义为每10000人口中麻风病病例少于1例。由于多种机遇的汇聚,消除成为可能:科学方面(就目前所知的麻风病自然史)、技术方面(多药疗法和泡罩包装)、政治方面(政府承诺)和财政方面(例如日本基金会等非政府组织提供免费多药疗法的支持)机遇。消除引发了不切实际的期望,即麻风病问题能在2000年得到解决。首先,在一些麻风病高发地区,消除目标是不可行的。即使实现了消除,仍会有大量新的麻风病病例继续出现,许多因麻风病导致身体缺陷、严重心理、经济和社会问题的人将需要持续援助。麻风分枝杆菌的非人宿主、麻风病与贫困的关系、残疾预防、缺乏检测亚临床感染的可靠实验室检测方法以及疫苗也是具有挑战性的问题。
有了多药疗法泡罩包装,现有关于麻风病消除的证据非常积极。有人担心麻风病并非适合作为消除目标的疾病,因为缺乏检测亚临床感染的可靠诊断方法,包括没有疫苗、存在非人宿主(猴子和犰狳)、儿童病例负担增加、没有良好的流行病学指标(用患病率而非发病率来衡量消除情况)。多药疗法能很好地治疗麻风病,但没有证据表明它能同时阻断传播。高社会污名、残疾预防以及麻风病与贫困的关系仍然是主要问题。