Andrology Australia, c/o Monash Institute of Medical Research, Monash University, Clayton, Vic, Australia.
Soc Sci Med. 2012 Jan;74(2):228-35. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2011.10.015. Epub 2011 Dec 1.
While focussing on influential actors within a policy network may provide insight into the shaping of policy, it fails to elucidate how the network itself may moderate the behaviours of actors when participating in the policy process. Applying Skok's (1995) structural-functional framework, this study explores whether network analysis provides an alternative analytical approach to explain how the broader structural features of the network may influence actors participating in different functional phases of the policy cycle. To illustrate the rationale for a network analysis approach to policy analysis, we introduce the 2010 Australian National Male Health Policy, as an illustrative case of a network of competing interests within the broader health policy domain. An analysis of the associated men's health network and the network structures that exist for different relational purposes identified a weak (low density) network, which lacked a hierarchical structure, and where levels of reciprocity between actors was low. Network characteristics changed depending on the relationship type between actors, highlighting the dynamic nature of networks and reflecting the different imperatives of the policy process. An understanding of network structures gained from the network analysis approach described in this study potentially provides policy-makers, and stakeholders, with an alternative tool to stakeholder analysis when considering engagement with the policy process.
虽然关注政策网络中的有影响力的参与者可以深入了解政策的形成过程,但它未能阐明网络本身在参与者参与政策过程时如何调节参与者的行为。本研究应用 Skok(1995)的结构功能框架,探讨网络分析是否提供了一种替代的分析方法,以解释网络的更广泛结构特征如何影响在政策周期不同功能阶段参与的行为者。为了说明采用网络分析方法进行政策分析的基本原理,我们以澳大利亚 2010 年国家男性健康政策为例,说明了更广泛健康政策领域内竞争利益的网络。对相关男性健康网络及其存在的不同关系目的的网络结构进行分析后发现,网络是弱连接(密度低)的,缺乏等级结构,行为者之间的互惠程度较低。网络特征根据行为者之间的关系类型而变化,突出了网络的动态性质,并反映了政策过程的不同紧迫性。通过本研究中描述的网络分析方法获得的网络结构的理解,为决策者和利益相关者提供了一种替代利益相关者分析的工具,以考虑在政策过程中的参与。