Suckow Bjoern D, Goodney Philip P, Cambria Robert A, Bertges Daniel J, Eldrup-Jorgensen Jens, Indes Jeffrey E, Schanzer Andres, Stone David H, Kraiss Larry W, Cronenwett Jack L
Division of Vascular Surgery, University of Utah Hospital, University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT 84132, USA.
Ann Vasc Surg. 2012 Jan;26(1):67-78. doi: 10.1016/j.avsg.2011.07.014.
Some patients who undergo lower extremity bypass (LEB) for critical limb ischemia ultimately require amputation. The functional outcome achieved by these patients after amputation is not well known. Therefore, we sought to characterize the functional outcome of patients who undergo amputation after LEB, and to describe the pre- and perioperative factors associated with independent ambulation at home after lower extremity amputation.
Within a cohort of 3,198 patients who underwent an LEB between January, 2003 and December, 2008, we studied 436 patients who subsequently received an above-knee (AK), below-knee (BK), or minor (forefoot or toe) ipsilateral or contralateral amputation. Our main outcome measure consisted of a "good functional outcome," defined as living at home and ambulating independently. We calculated univariate and multivariate associations among patient characteristics and our main outcome measure, as well as overall survival.
Of the 436 patients who underwent amputation within the first year following LEB, 224 of 436 (51.4%) had a minor amputation, 105 of 436 (24.1%) had a BK amputation, and 107 of 436 (24.5%) had an AK amputation. The majority of AK (75 of 107, 72.8%) and BK amputations (72 of 105, 70.6%) occurred in the setting of bypass graft thrombosis, whereas nearly all minor amputations (200 of 224, 89.7%) occurred with a patent bypass graft. By life-table analysis at 1 year, we found that the proportion of surviving patients with a good functional outcome varied by the presence and extent of amputation (proportion surviving with good functional outcome = 88% no amputation, 81% minor amputation, 55% BK amputation, and 45% AK amputation, p = 0.001). Among those analyzed at long-term follow-up, survival was slightly lower for those who had a minor amputation when compared with those who did not receive an amputation after LEB (81 vs. 88%, p = 0.02). Survival among major amputation patients did not significantly differ compared with no amputation (BK amputation 87%, p = 0.14, AK amputation 89%, p = 0.27); however, this part of the analysis was limited by its sample size (n = 212). In multivariable analysis, we found that the patients most likely to remain ambulatory and live independently despite undergoing a lower extremity amputation were those living at home preoperatively (hazard ratio [HR]: 6.8, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.94-49, p = 0.058) and those with preoperative statin use (HR: 1.6, 95% CI: 1.2-2.1, p = 0.003), whereas the presence of several comorbidities identified patients less likely to achieve a good functional outcome: coronary disease (HR: 0.6, 95% CI: 0.5-0.9, p = 0.003), dialysis (HR: 0.5, 95% CI: 0.3-0.9, p = 0.02), and congestive heart failure (HR: 0.5, 95% CI: 0.3-0.8, p = 0.005).
A postoperative amputation at any level impacts functional outcomes following LEB surgery, and the extent of amputation is directly related to the effect on functional outcome. It is possible, based on preoperative patient characteristics, to identify patients undergoing LEB who are most or least likely to achieve good functional outcomes even if a major amputation is ultimately required. These findings may assist in patient education and surgical decision making in patients who are poor candidates for lower extremity bypass.
一些因严重肢体缺血而接受下肢搭桥术(LEB)的患者最终需要截肢。这些患者截肢后的功能结局尚不清楚。因此,我们试图描述LEB术后截肢患者的功能结局,并描述与下肢截肢后在家中独立行走相关的术前和围手术期因素。
在2003年1月至2008年12月期间接受LEB的3198例患者队列中,我们研究了436例随后接受同侧或对侧膝上(AK)、膝下(BK)或小截肢(前足或趾)的患者。我们的主要结局指标包括“良好的功能结局”,定义为在家居住且能独立行走。我们计算了患者特征与主要结局指标以及总生存率之间的单变量和多变量关联。
在LEB术后第一年内接受截肢的436例患者中,436例中的224例(51.4%)接受了小截肢,436例中的105例(24.1%)接受了BK截肢,436例中的107例(24.5%)接受了AK截肢。大多数AK截肢(107例中的75例,72.8%)和BK截肢(105例中的72例,70.6%)发生在旁路移植血管血栓形成的情况下,而几乎所有小截肢(224例中的200例,89.7%)发生在旁路移植血管通畅的情况下。通过1年的生命表分析,我们发现存活且功能结局良好的患者比例因截肢的存在和程度而异(功能结局良好的存活比例=未截肢者为88%,小截肢者为81%,BK截肢者为55%,AK截肢者为45%,p = 0.001)。在长期随访分析的患者中,接受小截肢的患者生存率略低于LEB术后未接受截肢的患者(81%对88%,p = 0.02)。与未截肢相比,大截肢患者的生存率无显著差异(BK截肢为87%,p = 0.14,AK截肢为89%,p = 0.27);然而,这部分分析受样本量限制(n = 212)。在多变量分析中,我们发现尽管接受了下肢截肢但最有可能保持行走能力并独立生活得患者是术前在家居住的患者(风险比[HR]:6.8,95%置信区间[CI]:0.94 - 49,p = 0.058)和术前使用他汀类药物的患者(HR:l.6,95% CI:1.2 - 2.1,p = 0.003),而存在几种合并症表明患者获得良好功能结局的可能性较小:冠心病(HR:0.6,95% CI:0.5 - 0.9,p = 0.003)、透析(HR:0.5,95% CI:0.3 - 0.9,p = 0.02)和充血性心力衰竭(HR:0.5,95% CI:0.3 - 0.8,p = 0.005)。
任何水平的术后截肢都会影响LEB手术后的功能结局,截肢程度与对功能结局的影响直接相关。根据术前患者特征,有可能识别出即使最终需要大截肢也最有可能或最不可能获得良好功能结局的LEB患者。这些发现可能有助于对下肢搭桥术不佳候选患者进行患者教育和手术决策。