Cronenwett Jack L, Likosky Donald S, Russell Margaret T, Eldrup-Jorgensen Jens, Stanley Andrew C, Nolan Brian W
Sections of Vascular Surgery, Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center, Lebanon, NH 03756, USA.
J Vasc Surg. 2007 Dec;46(6):1093-1101; discussion 1101-2. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2007.08.012. Epub 2007 Oct 24.
A regional cooperative data registry was organized for carotid endarterectomy (CEA), lower extremity bypass (LEB), and infrarenal abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) repair (open and endovascular) procedures in Northern New England to allow benchmarking among centers for quality assurance and improvement activities.
Since January 2003, 48 vascular surgeons from nine hospitals in Maine, New Hampshire, and Vermont (25 to 615 beds) have prospectively recorded patient, procedure, and in-hospital patient outcome data. Results plus 1-year follow-up data analyzed at a central site are reported anonymously to each center at semiannual meetings where care processes and regional benchmarks are discussed. Mortality and compliance with procedure entry were validated by independent comparison with hospital administrative data. Initial improvement efforts focused on optimizing preoperative medication usage.
A total of 6143 operations were entered into the registry through December 2006. In-hospital stroke or death after CEA was 1.0%, major amputation or death after LEB was 3.8%, and mortality was 2.9% after elective open and 0.4% after endovascular repair. Variation in results between centers and surgeons provides opportunity for further quality improvement. Any postoperative complication increased median length of stay by > or =3 days. Process improvement efforts initiated in 2004 increased preoperative beta-blocker administration from 72% to 91%, antiplatelet agents from 73% to 83%, and statins from 54% to 72% (all P < .001). Procedure volume and discharge status validation with administrative data led to 99% of appropriate operations being reported to the registry. Mortality was accurately reported to the data registry for all patients.
This validated regional data registry within a quality improvement initiative has been associated with improved preoperative medication usage. It provides a potential vehicle for future public and pay-for-performance reporting and has the potential to improve patient outcomes. It has been sustained for >4 years and is a model that could be adopted by other regions.
在新英格兰北部组织了一个区域合作数据登记处,用于登记颈动脉内膜切除术(CEA)、下肢搭桥术(LEB)和肾下腹主动脉瘤(AAA)修复术(开放手术和血管内修复术),以便各中心之间进行基准对比,开展质量保证和改进活动。
自2003年1月以来,来自缅因州、新罕布什尔州和佛蒙特州9家医院(床位25至615张)的48名血管外科医生前瞻性地记录了患者、手术及住院患者的预后数据。在半年一次的会议上,将在中心站点分析得出的结果及1年随访数据匿名报告给每个中心,会上会讨论护理流程和区域基准。通过与医院管理数据进行独立对比,对死亡率和手术记录的合规性进行验证。最初的改进工作集中在优化术前用药。
截至2006年12月,共有6143例手术被录入登记处。CEA术后院内卒中或死亡发生率为1.0%,LEB术后大截肢或死亡发生率为3.8%,择期开放修复术后死亡率为2.9%,血管内修复术后死亡率为0.4%。各中心和外科医生的结果存在差异,这为进一步提高质量提供了机会。任何术后并发症都会使中位住院时间延长≥3天。2004年启动的流程改进措施使术前β受体阻滞剂的使用率从72%提高到91%,抗血小板药物的使用率从73%提高到83%,他汀类药物的使用率从54%提高到72%(所有P<.001)。通过管理数据对手术量和出院状态进行验证后,99%的合适手术被报告给了登记处。所有患者的死亡率都准确报告给了数据登记处。
这个在质量改进计划内经过验证的区域数据登记处与术前用药的改善相关。它为未来的公共报告和绩效付费报告提供了一个潜在的平台,并且有可能改善患者的预后。它已经持续了4年多,是一个可供其他地区采用的模式。