Clermont Université, Université d'Auvergne, Faculté de Chirurgie Dentaire, EA 3847, 11, Bd Charles de Gaulle, 63000 Clermont-Ferrand, France.
Clin Oral Investig. 2012 Dec;16(6):1599-606. doi: 10.1007/s00784-011-0663-3. Epub 2011 Dec 24.
Undertaking endodontic treatment under general anaesthesia (GA) is often described as difficult and hazardous, but no study reports on safe and efficacious conditions for endodontic treatment under GA. This study aims to evaluate whether compromises made for the endodontic treatment of permanent teeth under GA are acceptable. It describes the quality of endodontic treatment undertaken in two series of consecutive patients treated either under GA or local anaesthesia (LA).
Post-operative data sheets and periapical radiographs were collected for 255 permanent teeth treated under GA during a 4-year period (GA group, 125 patients with special needs) and for 246 permanent teeth treated under local anaesthesia over 7 months (LA group, 180 healthy patients). The radiographic criteria for quality of endodontic treatment (RCQET) were considered satisfactory when (1) the root filling was within 2 mm of the apex; (2) the filling displayed no voids or defects; and (3) all the visible canals had been obturated. The type of tooth, pulpal status and periapical status were considered independent variables for RCQET.
The proportion of satisfactory RCQET reached 63% in both groups and differed by type of tooth, being significantly lower for molars than for other teeth.
From a technical point of view, compromises made for the endodontic treatment of permanent teeth under GA are acceptable. Further studies should be conducted to evaluate the long-term success of endodontic treatment performed under GA.
This study supports the feasibility of endodontic treatment for patients treated under GA.
在全身麻醉(GA)下进行牙髓治疗通常被描述为困难和危险的,但没有研究报告 GA 下牙髓治疗的安全和有效条件。本研究旨在评估在 GA 下进行的恒牙牙髓治疗所做的妥协是否可以接受。它描述了在 GA 或局部麻醉(LA)下连续治疗的两批连续患者的牙髓治疗质量。
在 4 年期间(GA 组,125 名有特殊需求的患者)为 255 颗在 GA 下治疗的恒牙和在 7 个月内(LA 组,180 名健康患者)为 246 颗在局部麻醉下治疗的恒牙收集术后数据表和根尖射线照片。当(1)根充在根尖 2mm 内;(2)充填物无空隙或缺陷;(3)所有可见的根管均已堵塞时,认为根管治疗质量的放射学标准(RCQET)是令人满意的。RCQET 的独立变量为牙齿类型、牙髓状态和根尖状态。
两组中 RCQET 达到满意的比例均为 63%,且与牙齿类型有关,磨牙的比例明显低于其他牙齿。
从技术角度来看,GA 下恒牙牙髓治疗所做的妥协是可以接受的。应进一步开展研究以评估 GA 下进行的牙髓治疗的长期成功率。
本研究支持 GA 下治疗的患者进行牙髓治疗的可行性。