Pennes D R, Naylor B, Rebner M
Department of Radiology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.
Acta Cytol. 1990 Sep-Oct;34(5):673-6.
The sensitivity of fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy of the breast as a function of the number of aspirations performed on any given lesion was investigated. Four separate aspirations each were performed on over 400 lesions of the breast, 93 of which yielded a cytologic diagnosis. The incremental diagnostic yields of each subsequent aspiration were tabulated. The first aspirate of the sequence gave the greatest yield, with smaller incremental yields on the second through the fourth aspirates. Benign and malignant lesions gave similar results, as did palpable and nonpalpable lesions (the latter being usually smaller in size). A mathematical extrapolation of the data indicates that three or four aspirations of any given lesion provide the optimal yield within the limits of practicality. This performance of multiple FNA biopsies is particularly important when the pathologist does not perform the biopsy, or is unable to assist in the immediate interpretation of the specimen to assess its adequacy.
研究了乳腺细针穿刺(FNA)活检的敏感性与对任何给定病变进行穿刺的次数之间的关系。对400多个乳腺病变分别进行了4次穿刺,其中93个病变获得了细胞学诊断。将每次后续穿刺的诊断增加率制成表格。该序列的第一次穿刺诊断率最高,第二次至第四次穿刺的诊断增加率较小。良性和恶性病变的结果相似,可触及和不可触及的病变(后者通常尺寸较小)也是如此。数据的数学推断表明,在实际可行的范围内,对任何给定病变进行三次或四次穿刺可获得最佳诊断率。当病理学家不进行活检,或无法协助立即解读标本以评估其充分性时,多次FNA活检的这种表现尤为重要。