Department of Neurology, Johannes Gutenberg University, Mainz, Germany.
Neuroimage. 2012 Mar;60(1):162-9. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2011.12.032. Epub 2011 Dec 23.
Contrary to most other sensory systems, no consensus has been reached within the scientific community about the exact locations and functions of human cortical areas processing vestibular information. Metaanalytical modelling using activation likelihood estimation (ALE) for the integration of neuroimaging results has already been successfully applied to several distinct tasks, thereby revealing the cortical localization of cognitive functions. We used the same algorithm and technique with all available and suitable PET and fMRI studies employing a vestibular stimulus. Most consistently across 28 experiments vestibular stimuli evoked activity in the right hemispheric parietal opercular area OP 2 implicating it as the core region for vestibular processing. Furthermore, we took our primary results as a seeding point and fed them into a functional connectivity analysis based on resting-state oscillations in 100 healthy subjects. This subsequent calculation confirmed direct connections of the area OP 2 with every other region found in the meta-analysis, in particular temporo-parietal regions, premotor cortex, and the midcingulate gyrus. Thus revealing a joint vestibular network in accordance with a concept from animal literature termed the inner vestibular circle. Moreover, there was also a significant vestibular connectivity overlap with frontal but not parietal cortical centres responsible for the generation of saccadic eye movements, likely to be involved in nystagmus fast phase generation. This was shown in an additional ocular motor meta-analysis. We conclude that the cytoarchitectonic area OP 2 in the parietal operculum, embedded in a joint vestibular network, should be the primary candidate for the human vestibular cortex. This area may represent the human homologue to the vestibular area PIVC as proposed by Guldin and Grüsser in non-human primates.
与大多数其他感觉系统不同,科学界尚未就处理前庭信息的人类皮质区域的确切位置和功能达成共识。使用激活似然估计 (ALE) 对神经影像学结果进行的荟萃分析建模已经成功应用于几个不同的任务,从而揭示了认知功能的皮质定位。我们使用相同的算法和技术,对所有使用前庭刺激的可用且合适的 PET 和 fMRI 研究进行了分析。在 28 项实验中,最一致的是,前庭刺激会在右侧半球顶叶的 OP2 区引起活动,这表明它是前庭处理的核心区域。此外,我们将主要结果作为种子点,并将其输入到基于 100 名健康受试者静息状态振荡的功能连接分析中。随后的计算证实了区域 OP2 与元分析中发现的每个其他区域的直接连接,特别是颞顶叶区域、前运动皮层和中扣带回。因此,根据动物文献中称为“内前庭环”的概念,揭示了一个共同的前庭网络。此外,与负责扫视眼运动产生的额皮质中心而不是顶皮质中心也存在显著的前庭连接重叠,这可能与眼球震颤快相产生有关。在额外的眼球运动荟萃分析中显示了这一点。我们得出的结论是,位于顶叶脑回的 OP2 区位于共同的前庭网络中,应该是人类前庭皮质的主要候选区域。该区域可能代表了非人类灵长类动物 Guldin 和 Grüsser 提出的前庭区 PIVC 的人类同源物。