Victoria University of Wellington & Centre for Applied Cross-Cultural Research, New Zealand.
Int J Psychol. 2012;47(3):211-21. doi: 10.1080/00207594.2011.617372. Epub 2012 Jan 12.
One of the important challenges facing psychologists of religion pertains to the definition of religiosity and spirituality. One way of understanding the connection between these two concepts is to suppose that one of them is a subset of the other. Another useful and sensitive way, however, is to view spirituality and religiosity as overlapping constructs, sharing some characteristics but also retaining nonshared features. Empirical studies examining the factor structure of spirituality and religiosity are scant and almost all of them come from Western culture. These factor analytic studies generally confirm that religiosity and spirituality can best be described in terms of two distinct yet correlated factors. To date, no study has investigated the relationship between these two constructs in Islamic cultures. To redress this imbalance, confirmatory factor analysis was used to examine the factor structure of religiosity and spirituality in two Iranian Shiite samples using an extensive set of scales (including Santa Clara Strength of Religious Faith, Spiritual Involvement and Beliefs Scale - Revised, Spiritual Meaning Scale, and Spiritual Transcendence Scale). Two hypothetical models were tested: a model that viewed spirituality and religiosity as correlated but separate constructs and a model that combined the indicators of religiosity and spirituality into a single construct. In keeping with the results obtained in Western cultures, results of confirmatory factor analyses, conducted in Study 1 (N=225) and Study 2 (N=288), revealed that a two-factor model fitted the data better than a single-factor model. Implications of the results are discussed, as are study limitations and directions for further research.
宗教心理学家面临的重要挑战之一与宗教信仰和精神信仰的定义有关。理解这两个概念之间联系的一种方法是假设其中一个概念是另一个概念的子集。然而,另一种有用且敏感的方法是将精神信仰和宗教信仰视为重叠的结构,它们具有一些共同特征,但也保留了不共享的特征。关于精神信仰和宗教信仰的结构因素的实证研究很少,而且几乎所有这些研究都来自西方文化。这些因素分析研究通常证实,宗教信仰和精神信仰最好用两个不同但相关的因素来描述。迄今为止,没有研究调查过伊斯兰文化中这两个结构之间的关系。为了纠正这种不平衡,使用验证性因素分析在两个伊朗什叶派样本中检验了宗教信仰和精神信仰的结构因素,使用了一套广泛的量表(包括圣克拉拉宗教信仰强度量表、修订后的精神投入和信仰量表、精神意义量表和精神超越量表)。测试了两种假设模型:一种模型认为精神信仰和宗教信仰是相关但独立的结构,另一种模型将宗教信仰和精神信仰的指标结合到一个单一的结构中。与西方文化中获得的结果一致,在研究 1(N=225)和研究 2(N=288)中进行的验证性因素分析的结果表明,双因素模型比单因素模型更适合数据。讨论了结果的含义,以及研究的局限性和进一步研究的方向。