Kioulos K T, Bergiannaki J D, Glaros A, Vassiliadou M, Alexandri Z, Papadimitriou G
1st Department of Psychiatry, University of Athens, Medical School, Eginition Hospital, Athens.
Department of Social Theology, Faculty of Theology, University of Athens.
Psychiatriki. 2015 Jan-Mar;26(1):38-44.
The quest for existential meaning constitutes a universal phenomenon traditionally manifested in official religions (religiosity) or personal modes of transcendence (spirituality). Religiosity and spirituality have been found to be associated with a variety of mental health and illness parameters. In the last decades there is an increasing number of publications with interesting results on the relationship between religiosity and mental health, both on a theoretical and a clinical level. Recent research suggests the presence of clinically important interactions between religious beliefs and mental health, although the exact nature of the associations remains unclear. The aim of the present study is to investigate subjective health status in relation to specific dimensions of religiosity and spirituality in Greek students; 202 students of the faculty of Theology of the University of Athens were interviewed using the Brief Multidimensional Measurement of Religiousness/Spirituality (BMMRS), which assesses the dimensions of "daily spiritual experiences", "meaning", "values/beliefs", "forgiveness", "private religious practices", "religious/spiritual coping", "religious support", "religious/ spiritual history", "commitment", "organizational religiousness", and "religious preferences". Subjective health status was measured by the General Health Questionnaire (GHQ-28) which examines four areas of health in the following sub-scales: (a) somatic symptoms, (b) anxiety and insomnia, (c) social dysfunction and (d) severe depression. Pearson correlations coefficients and linear regression analyses were used to estimate the associations of GHQ-28 subscales with religiosity dimensions. High scores in each dimension of BMMRS corresponded to a low level of religiosity. The dimension of "daily spiritual experiences" was positively correlated with the subscales of anxiety/ insomnia, social dysfunction and severe depression, while the dimension of "values/beliefs" with social dysfunction and severe depression and the dimension of "forgiveness" with all GHQ-28 subscales. The "organizational religiousness" dimension was positively correlated with anxiety/ insomnia, while overall self-ranking with social dysfunction and severe depression. Additionally, the dimension of "meaning" had a negative correlation with somatic symptoms. Moreover, in the multiple linear regression analyses, "meaning" was independently negative associated with somatic symptoms (p=0.032), whilst "daily spiritual experiences" were positively associated with anxiety/insomnia (p=0.023). Also, "values/beliefs and the overall self-ranking were positively associated with social dysfunction (p=0.026), (p=0.01) and "daily spiritual experiences", "values/beliefs", "forgiveness", as well as the overall self-ranking with severe depression (p=0.03), (p=0.01), (p=0.017), (p=0.009). Certain religiosity dimensions ("daily spiritual experiences", "values/beliefs", "forgiveness" and "organizational religiousness") were correlated with lower morbidity, in accordance to previous reports in different populations, whereas "meaning" was correlated with more somatic symptoms.
对生存意义的追求是一种普遍现象,传统上体现在官方宗教(宗教信仰)或个人超越方式(精神性)中。宗教信仰和精神性已被发现与多种心理健康和疾病参数相关。在过去几十年里,关于宗教信仰与心理健康之间关系的理论和临床层面的有趣研究成果不断涌现。近期研究表明宗教信仰与心理健康之间存在临床上重要的相互作用,尽管这种关联的确切性质仍不清楚。本研究旨在调查希腊学生中与宗教信仰和精神性特定维度相关的主观健康状况;我们使用宗教性/精神性简短多维测量量表(BMMRS)对雅典大学神学院的202名学生进行了访谈,该量表评估“日常精神体验”“意义”“价值观/信仰”“宽恕”“私人宗教活动”“宗教/精神应对”“宗教支持”“宗教/精神历史”“承诺”“组织宗教性”以及“宗教偏好”等维度。主观健康状况通过一般健康问卷(GHQ - 28)进行测量,该问卷在以下子量表中考察四个健康领域:(a)躯体症状,(b)焦虑和失眠,(c)社会功能障碍,以及(d)严重抑郁。使用皮尔逊相关系数和线性回归分析来估计GHQ - 28子量表与宗教性维度之间的关联。BMMRS各维度得分高对应宗教信仰水平低。“日常精神体验”维度与焦虑/失眠、社会功能障碍和严重抑郁子量表呈正相关,而“价值观/信仰”维度与社会功能障碍和严重抑郁呈正相关,“宽恕”维度与所有GHQ - 28子量表呈正相关。“组织宗教性”维度与焦虑/失眠呈正相关,而总体自我排名与社会功能障碍和严重抑郁呈正相关。此外,“意义”维度与躯体症状呈负相关。而且,在多元线性回归分析中,“意义”与躯体症状独立呈负相关(p = 0.032),而“日常精神体验”与焦虑/失眠呈正相关(p = 0.023)。同样,“价值观/信仰”和总体自我排名与社会功能障碍呈正相关(p = 0.026),(p = 0.01),“日常精神体验”“价值观/信仰”“宽恕”以及总体自我排名与严重抑郁呈正相关(p = 0.03),(p = 0.