Integrated Safety Support, PO Box 2343, Fitzroy, Victoria 3065, Australia.
Accid Anal Prev. 2012 Mar;45 Suppl:36-40. doi: 10.1016/j.aap.2011.09.023. Epub 2011 Oct 5.
The causes of fatigue in truck drivers related to work hours have been studied extensively and are reasonably well understood. However, much less is known about how rest opportunities can be structured to optimise recovery from fatigue. The nature of the road transport industry often requires that rest be taken in various locations. New investigation in this area, focusing on sleep obtained in truck cabs and other non-home environments is critically important to complement existing understanding. This study examined sleep at home and in truck cabs, in truck drivers who were actively working during the time of the study. Thirty-seven male drivers aged between 24 and 63 years (age: 48.7 ± 9.0 years; mean ± SD) wore activity monitors (also known as 'sleep watches') and completed work and sleep diaries for a period of 21 days, recording their subjective fatigue levels before, during and after work shifts, and before and after sleep periods. They also self-rated their sleep quality and noted the number of times they woke during sleep periods. Analyses focused on home versus in-truck sleep periods. The subjective data suggested that a greater quantity (P<.001) and quality (P<.05) of sleep was obtained at home than in the truck, and that sleeping at home more effectively reduced fatigue levels (P<.001). The objective data showed trends towards longer sleep length at home, but other variables, including total sleep per 24h and sleep quality, showed no significant differences. This study demonstrates that measuring sleep quantity and quality in operational road transport environments is feasible. The findings caution against over-reliance on laboratory and simulator studies since there are critical aspects of the operating environment that cannot be validly studied in artificially controlled settings. This study is unique in its direct examination of sleep quantity and quality in truck drivers sleeping at home and away from home.
卡车司机与工作时间相关的疲劳原因已经得到了广泛的研究,并且已经有了比较充分的了解。然而,关于如何安排休息时间以优化疲劳恢复,人们的了解要少得多。道路运输行业的性质通常要求在不同的地点休息。在这一领域进行新的调查,重点研究卡车驾驶室和其他非家庭环境中获得的睡眠,对于补充现有认识至关重要。本研究检查了正在工作的卡车司机在家中和卡车内的睡眠情况。37 名年龄在 24 岁至 63 岁之间的男性司机(年龄:48.7±9.0 岁;均值±标准差)佩戴活动监测器(也称为“睡眠手表”),并在 21 天的时间内完成工作和睡眠日记,记录他们在工作班次前后以及睡眠前后的主观疲劳水平。他们还自我评估了睡眠质量,并记录了睡眠期间醒来的次数。分析集中在家中和卡车内的睡眠期。主观数据表明,在家中获得的睡眠时间(P<.001)和睡眠质量(P<.05)都更高,而且在家中睡眠更有效地降低了疲劳水平(P<.001)。客观数据显示,在家中睡眠时间更长,但其他变量,包括 24 小时内的总睡眠时间和睡眠质量,没有显著差异。本研究表明,在运营道路运输环境中测量睡眠量和睡眠质量是可行的。研究结果告诫人们不要过度依赖实验室和模拟研究,因为操作环境中有一些关键方面无法在人为控制的环境中进行有效研究。本研究的独特之处在于直接检查了在家中和离家时卡车司机的睡眠数量和质量。