Devitt J E
Can Med Assoc J. 1979 Jun 9;120(11):1370-72.
Most reports advocating mammography have been written by radiologists rather than by clinicians who are frequently confronted by women with breast complaints. The value of mammography in managing patients with breast problems was studied by reviewing its role in 1026 breast consultations; there were 129 patients with cancer. Mammography was performed in 95 patients. The procedure hastened the diagnosis of one comedocarcinoma, and in another patient was suspicious 3 years before she presented with a locally advanced lesion. It missed six cancers. In seven patients it recognized clinically obvious cancers, though in one of these it had given negative results 10 months before the patient presented with a lesion 15 cm in diameter. It also falsely suggested the possibility of cancer in 28 women. In the other 52 patients the clinical diagnosis of a benign condition was usually fairly evident. The morbidity caused by mammography does not seem to have been widely appreciated, no doubt because of the hope that clinically unrecognized cancers would be found by it. Most breast problems can be diagnosed without mammography.
大多数提倡乳腺钼靶检查的报告都是由放射科医生撰写的,而非那些经常面对有乳腺问题女性的临床医生。通过回顾乳腺钼靶检查在1026例乳腺会诊中的作用,研究了其在处理乳腺问题患者中的价值;其中有129例癌症患者。95例患者进行了乳腺钼靶检查。该检查加速了1例粉刺癌的诊断,在另1例患者中,在其出现局部进展性病变的3年前检查结果就可疑。它漏诊了6例癌症。在7例患者中,它识别出了临床上明显的癌症,尽管其中1例在患者出现直径15厘米的病变前10个月检查结果为阴性。它还在28名女性中错误地提示了患癌的可能性。在其他52例患者中,良性疾病的临床诊断通常相当明显。乳腺钼靶检查所造成的发病率似乎尚未得到广泛认识,这无疑是因为人们希望通过它能发现临床上未被识别的癌症。大多数乳腺问题无需乳腺钼靶检查即可诊断。