Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA.
Pain Physician. 2012 Jan-Feb;15(1):87-93.
Epidural injection of corticosteroids is a commonly used treatment for radicular pain. However, the benefits are often short lived, and repeated injections are often limited secondary to concerns of side effects from cumulative steroid doses. In addition, rare, catastrophic complications, including brain and spinal cord embolic infarcts have been attributed to particulate steroid injections. A previous study has shown that dexamethasone has less particulate than other corticosteroids, possibly reducing embolic risk. Furthermore, a recent study indicated that clonidine may be useful in the treatment of radicular pain when administered via epidural steroid injection. The combination of corticosteroid and clonidine is an intriguing, yet unstudied, alternative to traditional treatment.
Our study examines whether mixing clonidine and various corticosteroids results in increased particle size or aggregation.
Evaluations under light microscopy for particle size were made of samples of clonidine alone and clonidine mixed with equal parts of 3 corticosteroids solutions: dexamethasone sodium phosphate injection, triamcinolone acetonide injectable suspension, and betamethasone sodium phosphate and betamethasone acetate injectable suspension. Four mL each of clonidine (100 μcg/mL), clonidine (100 μcg/mL) + dexamethasone sodium phosphate injection (4 mg/mL), clonidine (100 μcg/mL) + triamcinolone acetonide injectable suspension (40 mg/mL), and clonidine (100 μcg/mL) + betamethasone sodium phosphate and betamethasone acetate injectable suspension (6 mg/mL) were examined Their particle sizes were compared to measurements taken when each steroid solution was examined alone.
Clonidine was determined to be nonparticulate when examined by light microscopy. Clonidine mixed with equal parts of each of the 3 corticosteroids mentioned above did not result in increased clumping or increased particle size over each of the corticosteroids measured alone.
Mixing clonidine with corticosteroids did not increase particulation compared to corticosteroids alone. Combining clonidine and corticosteroids for epidural injection may prove to be a useful treatment for radicular pain. The combination of these is unlikely to result in a solution that is more likely to cause embolic infarcts than the use of corticosteroids alone.
硬膜外注射皮质类固醇是治疗神经根痛的常用方法。然而,其益处往往是短暂的,由于担心累积类固醇剂量的副作用,反复注射往往受到限制。此外,还归因于颗粒状类固醇注射的罕见、灾难性并发症,包括脑和脊髓栓塞性梗死。先前的一项研究表明,地塞米松的颗粒状物质比其他皮质类固醇少,可能降低栓塞风险。此外,最近的一项研究表明,氯胺酮通过硬膜外类固醇注射治疗神经根痛可能是有用的。皮质类固醇和氯胺酮的联合是一种有趣但尚未研究的替代传统治疗方法。
我们的研究旨在检查氯胺酮与各种皮质类固醇混合是否会导致粒径增大或聚集。
对氯胺酮单独和氯胺酮与 3 种皮质类固醇溶液(磷酸地塞米松钠注射液、曲安奈德可注射混悬液和磷酸倍他米松和醋酸倍他米松可注射混悬液)等分混合的样本进行光镜下的粒径评估。分别对氯胺酮(100μg/ml)、氯胺酮(100μg/ml)+磷酸地塞米松钠注射液(4mg/ml)、氯胺酮(100μg/ml)+曲安奈德可注射混悬液(40mg/ml)和氯胺酮(100μg/ml)+磷酸倍他米松和醋酸倍他米松可注射混悬液(6mg/ml)进行了 4ml 的评估。比较了每种类固醇溶液单独检查时的粒径测量值。
光镜检查发现氯胺酮是非颗粒状的。氯胺酮与上述 3 种皮质类固醇中的每一种等份混合,不会导致团块增加或粒径增加超过单独测量的每一种皮质类固醇。
与单独使用皮质类固醇相比,氯胺酮与皮质类固醇混合不会增加颗粒度。将氯胺酮与皮质类固醇混合用于硬膜外注射可能被证明是治疗神经根痛的有效方法。与单独使用皮质类固醇相比,这种组合不太可能导致更有可能引起栓塞性梗死的溶液。