UO Senologia Clinica e Screening Mammografico, Dipartimento di Radiodiagnostica, APSS, Via Degasperi, 79, 38100 Trento, Italy.
Breast Cancer Res Treat. 2012 May;133(1):267-71. doi: 10.1007/s10549-012-1959-y. Epub 2012 Jan 22.
There is limited evidence on the role of 3D mammography with tomosynthesis in breast screening, although early studies suggest that it may improve specificity. We prospectively evaluated the effect of integrating 3D mammography as a triage to assessment in 158 consecutive recalls to assessment (recalled in standard 2D-mammographic screening) in asymptomatic subjects. Radiologists provided 3D mammography-based opinion as to whether recall/assessment was warranted or unnecessary, and all subjects proceeded to assessment. 3D triage was positive (confirmed the need for assessment) in all 21 subjects with breast cancer (there were no false negatives), and would have avoided recall in 102 of 137 (74.4%) subjects with a negative/benign final outcome in whom 3D triage did not recommend recall. Proportion of true negative 3D triage (as a proxy for potential reduction in recalls) was slightly higher in dense than non-dense breasts, did not differ across age-groups, but was significantly associated with the type of lesion seen on imaging (being highest for distortions, asymmetric densities, and lesions with ill-defined margins). While the simulation design may have over-estimated the potential for 3D mammography triage to reduce recalls, this study clearly demonstrates its capability to improve breast screening specificity and to reduce recall rates. Future studies of 3D mammography should further assess its role as a recall-reducing strategy in screening practice and should include formal cost-analysis.
关于三维断层合成乳腺摄影在乳腺筛查中的作用,证据有限,尽管早期研究表明它可能提高特异性。我们前瞻性地评估了将三维断层合成乳腺摄影作为一种分诊方法,用于评估 158 例连续召回评估(在标准二维乳腺筛查中召回)的效果在无症状受试者中。放射科医生根据 3D 乳房摄影的结果,判断是否需要召回/评估,所有受试者都进行了评估。在所有 21 例乳腺癌患者中,3D 分诊均为阳性(证实需要评估)(无假阴性),并且在 137 例阴性/良性最终结果的患者中,102 例(74.4%)不需要召回,3D 分诊不建议召回。在致密性和非致密性乳房中,3D 分诊的真阴性比例(作为潜在召回减少的替代指标)略高,但在年龄组之间没有差异,而与影像学所见病变类型显著相关(在结构扭曲、不对称密度和边界不清晰的病变中最高)。虽然模拟设计可能高估了 3D 乳房摄影分诊减少召回的潜力,但本研究清楚地表明了它提高乳腺筛查特异性和降低召回率的能力。未来的 3D 乳房摄影研究应进一步评估其在筛查实践中作为减少召回策略的作用,并应包括正式的成本分析。