Hanly C
Int J Psychoanal. 1990;71 ( Pt 3):375-83.
A philosophical controversy concerning the nature of truth has begun to play an important part in psychoanalytic theorizing. The two major philosophical notions, the coherence and the correspondence theories and their use in psychoanalytic theory making, are examined. It is argued that although coherence is part of the criteria of truth, correspondence is the more essential and fundamental criterion. It was in this way that Freud used these concepts in creating psychoanalysis. Psychoanalytic discoveries concerning the psychogenesis of objectivity in perception and thought support the correspondence theory of truth and provide, in addition, an answer to the third party critique of correspondence. The correspondence theory as a basic attitude of mind is a necessary element in the respect for the patient upon which psychoanalytic therapy depends.
一场关于真理本质的哲学争论已开始在精神分析理论构建中发挥重要作用。本文考察了两种主要的哲学观念,即融贯论和符合论,以及它们在精神分析理论构建中的应用。文章认为,虽然融贯性是真理标准的一部分,但符合才是更本质、更基本的标准。弗洛伊德正是以这种方式在创建精神分析时运用了这些概念。精神分析关于感知和思维中客观性的心理发生的发现支持了真理符合论,此外,还为对符合论的第三方批评提供了答案。符合论作为一种基本的思维态度,是精神分析治疗所依赖的对患者尊重的必要要素。