Department of Philosophy, Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Bogotá, Colombia.
Behav Brain Sci. 2012 Feb;35(1):36-7. doi: 10.1017/S0140525X11001312.
In a unified theory of human reciprocity, the strong and weak forms are similar because neither is biologically altruistic and both require normative motivation to support cooperation. However, strong reciprocity is necessary to support cooperation in public goods games. It involves inflicting costs on defectors; and though the costs for punishers are recouped, recouping costs requires complex institutions that would not have emerged if weak reciprocity had been enough.
在统一的人类互惠理论中,强互惠和弱互惠形式相似,因为它们都不是生物学意义上的利他主义,并且都需要规范动机来支持合作。然而,强互惠对于支持公共物品博弈中的合作是必要的。它涉及对背叛者施加成本;尽管惩罚者的成本会得到补偿,但补偿成本需要复杂的制度,如果弱互惠就足够了,这些制度就不会出现。