Collins John P, Smith Merrilyn J, Lambert Trevor, Hillis David J
Royal Australasian College of Surgeons, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
ANZ J Surg. 2011 Jun;81(6):411-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1445-2197.2011.05777.x.
The education and training of tomorrow’s surgeons are predicated upon the involvement of a broad spectrum of surgical educators. Identification of the factors that influence their ongoing participation is crucial for its continuity.
A study was performed on 695 surgeons identified as having major involvement in surgical education and training using a questionnaire based on a number of educational themes.
Four hundred and thirty-eight surgeons (63%) completed the questionnaire. The majority found teaching rewarding and would recommend it to colleagues, although fewer would advocate being a supervisor or course instructor. The highest motivating factors were sharing knowledge, enjoyment of teaching, necessity to remain up to date and the interaction that teaching provides with colleagues. Barriers included insufficient time because of other work commitments, lack of support from hospital management and intrusion on work–life balance. Surgeons saw themselves as successful in answering trainees’ questions, appropriately delegating patient care, providing feedback and creating a positive learning environment. They were least confident in helping trainees to identify their learning needs and develop their learning goals. New courses were considered desirable in assessment, providing feedback and the management of underperforming trainees.
Enjoyment of teaching, sharing knowledge and the requirement to keep up to date, motivate surgeons to teach. Lack of time for teaching, and lack of recognition and support act as barriers. Designated time for teaching, being equipped for the educational roles involved, and the provision of appropriate recognition and support are necessary to sustain this essential resource.
未来外科医生的教育与培训依赖于广泛的外科教育工作者的参与。识别影响他们持续参与的因素对于其连续性至关重要。
对695名被确定为主要参与外科教育与培训的外科医生进行了一项研究,使用基于多个教育主题的问卷。
438名外科医生(63%)完成了问卷。大多数人认为教学有意义,并会向同事推荐,尽管较少有人会主张担任导师或课程教员。最高的激励因素是分享知识、享受教学、跟上时代的必要性以及教学提供的与同事的互动。障碍包括由于其他工作任务而时间不足、缺乏医院管理层的支持以及对工作与生活平衡的干扰。外科医生认为自己在回答学员问题、合理分配患者护理、提供反馈以及营造积极的学习环境方面很成功。他们在帮助学员识别学习需求和制定学习目标方面最缺乏信心。新的课程在评估、提供反馈以及管理表现不佳的学员方面被认为是可取的。
对教学的享受、知识的分享以及跟上时代的要求激励着外科医生进行教学。教学时间不足以及缺乏认可和支持成为障碍。为教学指定时间、具备履行所涉教育角色的能力以及提供适当的认可和支持对于维持这一重要资源是必要的。