Department of Computer Science, University of Copenhagen, Denmark.
Acad Radiol. 2012 Apr;19(4):446-54. doi: 10.1016/j.acra.2011.12.012. Epub 2012 Feb 4.
Risk assessment of future osteoporotic vertebral fractures is currently based mainly on risk factors, such as bone mineral density, age, prior fragility fractures, and smoking. It can be argued that an osteoporotic vertebral fracture is not exclusively an abrupt event but the result of a decaying process. To evaluate fracture risk, a shape-based classifier, identifying possible small prefracture deformities, may be constructed.
During a longitudinal case-control study, a large population of postmenopausal women, fracture free at baseline, were followed. The 22 women who sustained at least one lumbar fracture on follow-up represented the case group. The control group comprised 91 women who maintained skeletal integrity and matched the case group according to the standard osteoporosis risk factors. On radiographs, a radiologist and two technicians independently performed manual annotations of the vertebrae, and fracture prediction using shape features extracted from the baseline annotations was performed. This was implemented using posterior probabilities from a standard linear classifier.
The classifier tested on the study population quantified vertebral fracture risk, giving statistically significant results for the radiologist annotations (area under the curve, 0.71 ± 0.013; odds ratio, 4.9; 95% confidence interval, 2.94-8.05).
The shape-based classifier provided meaningful information for the prediction of vertebral fractures. The approach was tested on case and control groups matched for osteoporosis risk factors. Therefore, the method can be considered an additional biomarker, which combined with traditional risk factors can improve population selection (eg, in clinical trials), identifying patients with high fracture risk.
目前,骨质疏松性椎体骨折的未来风险评估主要基于危险因素,如骨密度、年龄、既往脆性骨折和吸烟。可以认为,骨质疏松性椎体骨折不仅是一个突然的事件,而是一个衰退过程的结果。为了评估骨折风险,可以构建一种基于形状的分类器,识别可能的小骨折前变形。
在一项纵向病例对照研究中,对大量绝经后妇女进行了随访,这些妇女在基线时无骨折。在随访中至少发生 1 次腰椎骨折的 22 名妇女为病例组。对照组包括 91 名妇女,她们保持骨骼完整,并根据标准骨质疏松危险因素与病例组匹配。在 X 线片上,由 1 名放射科医生和 2 名技术员独立对椎体进行手动标注,并使用从基线标注中提取的形状特征进行骨折预测。这是使用标准线性分类器的后验概率来实现的。
在研究人群中测试的分类器量化了椎体骨折风险,对放射科医生的标注有统计学显著意义(曲线下面积,0.71±0.013;优势比,4.9;95%置信区间,2.94-8.05)。
基于形状的分类器为预测椎体骨折提供了有意义的信息。该方法在匹配骨质疏松危险因素的病例组和对照组中进行了测试。因此,该方法可以被认为是一种额外的生物标志物,与传统危险因素相结合可以改善人群选择(例如临床试验),识别高骨折风险的患者。