Hanayama Aiko, Yamamoto Shuichi, Shibuya Yusuke
Scientific Investigation Laboratory, Aomori Prefectural Police Head Quarters, Shin-machi, Aomori 030-0801, Japan.
Shinrigaku Kenkyu. 2011 Dec;82(5):459-66. doi: 10.4992/jjpsy.82.459.
The effect of self-relevance of a non-critical item in the Concealed Information Test (CIT) was investigated. Respiration, skin conductance response (SCR), heart rate, and normalized pulse volume were recorded while performing the CIT using a stimulus set composed of 4 items (with one self-relevant item). Thirty participants were instructed to recognize one item as critical and the remaining items as non-critical (positive group), and 33 participants were instructed to recognize all items as non-critical (negative group). In the positive group, a differential reactivity was observed between the critical and non-critical items, despite the self-relevance of the non-critical item. In the negative group, a differential reactivity between the self-relevant and non-self-relevant items was observed for SCR only. However, when individual data were analyzed, there was a differential reactivity between self-relevant and non-self-relevant items on physiological measures other than SCR for some participants in the negative group. These results suggest that the self-relevance of a non-critical item might cause false positive results in "negative" participants, particularly when only SCR is used to assess differential reactivity.
本研究调查了非关键项目的自我相关性在隐蔽信息测试(CIT)中的影响。在使用由4个项目(其中一个为自我相关项目)组成的刺激集进行CIT时,记录了呼吸、皮肤电反应(SCR)、心率和标准化脉搏容积。30名参与者被指示将一个项目识别为关键项目,其余项目识别为非关键项目(阳性组),33名参与者被指示将所有项目识别为非关键项目(阴性组)。在阳性组中,尽管非关键项目具有自我相关性,但在关键项目和非关键项目之间观察到了差异反应性。在阴性组中,仅在SCR方面观察到自我相关项目和非自我相关项目之间的差异反应性。然而,当对个体数据进行分析时,阴性组中的一些参与者在除SCR之外的生理指标上,自我相关项目和非自我相关项目之间存在差异反应性。这些结果表明,非关键项目的自我相关性可能会在“阴性”参与者中导致假阳性结果,尤其是当仅使用SCR来评估差异反应性时。