Department of Psychology, University of Denver, CO 80208, USA.
J Consult Clin Psychol. 2012 Apr;80(2):211-21. doi: 10.1037/a0027224. Epub 2012 Feb 13.
Using a longitudinal, randomized controlled trial, this study assessed the impact of a community-based outreach versus a more traditional criminal justice system-based referral program on women's distress and safety following police-reported intimate partner abuse (IPA).
Women (N = 236 women) with police-reported IPA were randomly assigned to 1 of 2 interdisciplinary community-coordinated response program conditions: Outreach (community-based victim advocate outreach) or Referral (criminal justice system-based victim advocate referrals to community-based agencies). Participants were interviewed 3 times over a 1-year period: within 26 (median) days of police-reported IPA, 6 months later, and 12 months later. Primary outcome measures included posttraumatic stress disorder and depression symptom severity (Posttraumatic Stress Diagnostic Scale; Beck Depression Inventory-II), fear appraisals (Trauma Appraisal Questionnaire), IPA revictimization (Revised Conflict Tactics Scale), and readiness to leave the relationship with the abuser.
One year after the initial interview, women in the Outreach condition reported decreased PTSD and depression symptom severity and fear compared with women in the Referral condition. Although both conditions were unrelated to revictimization in the follow-up year, women in the Outreach condition reported greater readiness to leave the abuser and rated services as more helpful than women in the Referral condition.
This is one of the first studies to examine community-based outreach in the context of an interdisciplinary community coordinated response to police-reported IPA. The findings suggest that community-based outreach by victim advocates results in decreased distress levels, greater readiness to leave abusive relationships, and greater perceived helpfulness of services relative to system-based referrals.
本研究采用纵向随机对照试验,评估基于社区外展的方案与更传统的基于刑事司法系统的转介方案对女性在遭受警方报告的亲密伴侣虐待(IPA)后的痛苦和安全状况的影响。
本研究将 236 名遭受 IPA 的女性随机分配到 2 种跨学科社区协调应对方案中的 1 种:外展(基于社区的受害者倡导外展)或转介(基于刑事司法系统的受害者倡导转介至社区机构)。参与者在 1 年内接受了 3 次访谈:在警方报告 IPA 后的 26(中位数)天内、6 个月后和 12 个月后。主要结局指标包括创伤后应激障碍和抑郁症状严重程度(创伤后应激障碍诊断量表;贝克抑郁量表-Ⅱ)、恐惧评估(创伤评估问卷)、IPA 再受害(修订冲突策略量表)以及与施虐者断绝关系的准备情况。
初次访谈 1 年后,外展组女性报告 PTSD 和抑郁症状严重程度以及恐惧程度低于转介组女性。尽管在随访年中,两种方案都与再受害无关,但外展组女性比转介组女性更愿意离开施虐者,且对服务的评价更高。
这是首批在跨学科社区协调应对警方报告的 IPA 背景下研究社区外展的研究之一。研究结果表明,受害者倡导人士的社区外展可降低痛苦水平、增强离开受虐关系的意愿,以及提高对服务的感知有用性,而与基于系统的转介相比。