Cros D, Day T J, Shahani B T
Clinical Neurophysiology Laboratories, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston 02114.
Muscle Nerve. 1990 Nov;13(11):1076-82. doi: 10.1002/mus.880131110.
To assess the longitudinal dispersion of the stimulus induced by the magnetic coil, collision experiments were performed in seven normal ulnar nerves. A supramaximal electrical stimulus S1 was delivered at the wrist, and followed by a supramaximal stimulus S2 in the upper arm, which was either electrical (electrical collision studies), or magnetic (magnetic collision studies). The interstimulus interval was varied by 0.2 msec increments from the time of complete cancellation of the S2 evoked motor response onwards, to include the entire span of recovery of that compound motor action potential. Collision curves were obtained for both magnetic and electrical stimuli by plotting the amplitude of the motor response elicited by S2 as a function of the interstimulus interval. In all seven normal ulnar nerves, comparison of the collision curves showed that the S2 evoked motor response is restored significantly more slowly when magnetic stimulation is used. This finding is best explained by longitudinal dispersion of the stimulus induced by the magnetic coil relative to conventional electrical stimulation, the large fibers being stimulated further away from the coil than the small ones. This interpretation is confirmed by the findings obtained with the same method in two cases of ulnar neuropathy, and by comparison of different intensities of magnetic stimulation.
为评估磁线圈诱发刺激的纵向弥散,在七条正常尺神经上进行了碰撞实验。在腕部施加超强电刺激S1,随后在上臂施加超强刺激S2,S2可以是电刺激(电碰撞研究),也可以是磁刺激(磁碰撞研究)。从S2诱发的运动反应完全消失之时起,以0.2毫秒的增量改变刺激间隔,以涵盖复合运动动作电位恢复的整个时间段。通过绘制S2诱发的运动反应幅度作为刺激间隔的函数,获得了磁刺激和电刺激的碰撞曲线。在所有七条正常尺神经中,碰撞曲线的比较表明,使用磁刺激时,S2诱发的运动反应恢复明显更慢。相对于传统电刺激,磁线圈诱发刺激的纵向弥散能最好地解释这一发现,即大纤维比小纤维受到的刺激离线圈更远。在两例尺神经病变患者中采用相同方法获得的结果以及对不同强度磁刺激的比较证实了这一解释。