Deonarine Patricia, de Wet Carl, McGhee Alistair
Radiology Department, Glasgow Royal Infirmary, 84 Castle Street, Glasgow G4 0SF, UK.
BMC Res Notes. 2012 Feb 17;5:104. doi: 10.1186/1756-0500-5-104.
Computed tomographic pulmonary angiography (CTPA) is increasingly being used as first investigation for suspected pulmonary embolism (PE). The investigation has high predictive value, but is resource and time intensive and exposes patients to considerable radiation. Our aim was to assess the potential value of a negative d-dimer assay to exclude pulmonary emboli and reduce the number of performed CTPAs.
All CTPAs performed in a Scottish secondary care hospital for a fourteen month period were retrospectively reviewed. Collected data included the presence or absence of PE, d-dimer results and patient demographics. PE positive CTPAs were reviewed by a specialist panel.
Pulmonary embolisms were reported for 66/405 (16.3%) CTPAs and d-dimer tests were performed for 216 (53%). 186/216 (86%) patients had a positive and 30 (14%) a negative d-dimer result. The panel agreed 5/66 (7.6%) false positive examinations. The d-dimer assay's negative predictive value was 93.3% (95% CI = 76.5%-98.8%) based on the original number of positive CTPAs and 100% (95% CI = 85.9%-100%) based on expert review. Significant non-PE intrapulmonary pathology was reported for 312/405 (77.0) CTPAs, including 13 new diagnoses of carcinoma.
We found that a low d-dimer score excluded all pulmonary embolisms, after a further specialist panel review identified initial false positive reports. However, current evidence-based guidelines still recommend that clinicians combine a d-dimer result with a validated clinical risk score when selecting suitable patients for CTPA. This may result in better use of limited resources, prevent patients being exposed to unnecessary irradiation and prevent potential complications as a result of iodinated contrast.
计算机断层扫描肺动脉造影(CTPA)越来越多地被用作疑似肺栓塞(PE)的首选检查方法。该检查具有较高的预测价值,但资源和时间消耗大,且会使患者受到大量辐射。我们的目的是评估D-二聚体检测结果为阴性对排除肺栓塞及减少CTPA检查数量的潜在价值。
回顾性分析一家苏格兰二级医疗机构在14个月内进行的所有CTPA检查。收集的数据包括是否存在PE、D-二聚体检测结果及患者人口统计学信息。PE阳性的CTPA检查由专家小组进行评估。
405例CTPA检查中有66例(16.3%)报告有肺栓塞,216例(53%)进行了D-二聚体检测。216例患者中,186例(86%)D-二聚体检测结果为阳性,30例(14%)为阴性。专家小组认定5/66例(7.6%)为假阳性检查。基于最初的阳性CTPA检查数量,D-二聚体检测的阴性预测值为93.3%(95%CI = 76.5%-98.8%),基于专家评估则为100%(95%CI = 85.9%-100%)。405例CTPA检查中有312例(77.0%)报告有显著的非PE肺内病变,包括13例新诊断的癌症。
我们发现,经过专家小组进一步评估排除最初的假阳性报告后,低D-二聚体评分可排除所有肺栓塞。然而,当前基于证据的指南仍建议临床医生在为CTPA选择合适患者时,将D-二聚体检测结果与经过验证的临床风险评分相结合。这可能会更好地利用有限资源,防止患者受到不必要的辐射,并预防因碘造影剂导致的潜在并发症。