Nottingham University Business School Collaboration for Leadership in Applied Health Research and Care - Lincolnshire, Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire (CLAHRC-NDL), Jubilee Campus, Triumph Road, Nottingham NG8 1BB, UK.
Midwifery. 2012 Dec;28(6):e900-9. doi: 10.1016/j.midw.2012.01.004. Epub 2012 Feb 16.
despite an exponential rise in the number of medically initiated elective caesarean sections over the last two decades, women's experiences of this birth mode remain largely unknown. The aim of this study was to address this gap by describing women's experiences of medically necessary elective caesarean section.
a grounded theory approach was used to collect and analyse interview data collected from 28 Australian women who had an elective caesarean section for a medical reason, 14 of whom were also observed during their caesarean section. The analyses of the non-participant observations were used to contextualise the women's experiences.
prior to having their baby, women expected to play an active part in their caesarean section and to be supported to take up their 'mother' role as soon as their baby was delivered. Postnatally however, they reported having felt invisible, superfluous and disregarded during the event. There was evidence that hospital routines and processes contributed to women feeling displaced and unimportant in their baby's birth. Three sub-categories were formed from the analysis of the data that together are represented by the in-vivo label 'off everyone's radar'. These were 'just another case on an operating list', 'striving to be included while trying to behave' and 'unable to be my baby's mum'.
our findings suggest that when women are ignored during childbirth, any fear they hold may escalate into peritraumatic disassociation, which in turn has implications for women's postnatal mental and emotional health in the short and long term. In addition, the separation of the mother-baby dyad was found to have a devastating impact on maternal-newborn attachment that lasted well into the postnatal period. To optimise women's childbirth satisfaction and foster their attachment to their baby, both of which are essential for ongoing emotional well-being, it is vital that they are located at the centre of their birth experience and that if at all possible they are not separated from their newborn.
尽管在过去的二十年中,医学上引发的选择性剖宫产数量呈指数级增长,但女性对这种分娩方式的体验在很大程度上仍不为人知。本研究旨在通过描述女性对医学上必需的选择性剖宫产的体验来填补这一空白。
采用扎根理论方法,收集并分析了 28 名澳大利亚女性的访谈数据,这些女性因医疗原因选择剖宫产,其中 14 名女性在剖宫产过程中也被观察。对非参与者观察的分析用于使女性的经历具有背景。
在分娩前,女性期望在剖宫产中发挥积极作用,并在婴儿出生后得到支持,尽快承担起“母亲”的角色。然而,产后她们报告说,在事件发生期间感到自己被忽视、多余和被忽视。有证据表明,医院的常规和流程导致女性在婴儿出生时感到被取代和不重要。从数据分析中形成了三个亚类,共同由现场标签“在所有人的雷达之外”表示。这些亚类分别是“手术名单上的另一个病例”、“努力被包括在内,同时试图表现”和“无法成为我孩子的妈妈”。
我们的研究结果表明,当女性在分娩期间被忽视时,她们可能会感到恐惧升级为创伤后分离,这反过来又会对女性的产后短期和长期心理健康产生影响。此外,还发现母婴分离对母婴依恋产生了毁灭性的影响,这种影响持续到产后时期。为了优化女性的分娩满意度并培养她们对婴儿的依恋,这两者对于持续的情感健康都是至关重要的,必须将她们置于分娩体验的中心,如果可能的话,她们不应与新生儿分开。