Department of International Health, The Bloomberg School of Public Health, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, USA.
Epilepsy Behav. 2012 Mar;23(3):291-3. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2011.11.028. Epub 2012 Feb 16.
Accidental death in people with epilepsy (PWE) has been described in high income settings where the relative risk of death is known to be higher than in the standard population. Population-based studies of injury deaths among PWE in developing countries are uncommon.
A population-based verbal autopsy study in Matlab, Bangladesh, performed at a health and demographic surveillance system site (mean population 223,886 in 142 villages), was used to assess the possible causes of all deaths. All cases of accidental injury (2005-2008) were evaluated and compared between people with and without a diagnosis of epilepsy.
There were 12 accidental deaths among PWE (8 females, age range 12-58 years old) out of a total of 316 deaths due to accidental injuries (3.8% of all injury deaths). Causes of mortality were drowning (n=10) and burns (n=2). The proportion of deaths due to drowning among PWE was significantly higher than that of the standard population (83% (10/12) vs. 7% (21/304), relative risk 12.6 (95% CI, 7.7-20.7, p<0.0001)). Mortality due to injury in PWE occurred at a younger age compared to people without epilepsy (mean difference 20.7 years (95% CI 6.7, 34.3), p<0.004).
There is a high proportion of accidental deaths due to drowning in PWE in Bangladesh compared to the standard population. Given the risk of seasonal flooding and low level of formal education, programs targeting water safety for PWE at all ages should be emphasized, appropriate for level of ability.
在高收入国家,已经有研究报道过癫痫患者(PWE)的意外死亡,且其死亡的相对风险高于普通人群。在发展中国家,针对癫痫患者的伤害死亡进行基于人群的研究比较少见。
我们在孟加拉国 Matlab 进行了一项基于人群的尸检研究,该研究在一个健康和人口监测系统(平均人口 223886 人,142 个村庄)现场进行,旨在评估所有死亡病例的可能原因。评估了所有意外损伤病例(2005-2008 年),并比较了有和无癫痫诊断的患者之间的差异。
共有 12 例癫痫患者(8 名女性,年龄 12-58 岁)因意外损伤死亡,占所有因意外损伤导致的死亡病例(316 例)的 3.8%。死因包括溺水(n=10)和烧伤(n=2)。癫痫患者中因溺水导致的死亡率明显高于普通人群(83%(10/12)比 7%(21/304),相对风险 12.6(95%CI,7.7-20.7,p<0.0001))。癫痫患者因损伤导致的死亡年龄比无癫痫患者更小(平均差异 20.7 岁(95%CI 6.7,34.3),p<0.004)。
与普通人群相比,孟加拉国癫痫患者的溺水死亡比例很高。考虑到季节性洪水的风险和低水平的正规教育,应针对所有年龄段的癫痫患者强调水安全计划,适合其能力水平。