Kikumoto O
Department of Neurology and Psychiatry, Hiroshima University School of Medicine.
Seishin Shinkeigaku Zasshi. 1990;92(7):411-34.
A clinical study was made on depressive state following stroke using stroke patients in the chronic stage. There were 118 stroke patients in the present study and 25 patients (21.2%) satisfied the diagnostic criteria for major depressive syndrome of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Third Edition Revised (DSM-III-R). As for dispositional, social, and somatic factors, a tendency was observed for depressive state to develop at a high frequency among patients with a past history of mental disorder prior to development of stroke, patients residing in suburban area, patients engaged in domestic and agricultural work, and patients with a frequent history of physical disorders. A tendency was observed for depressive state to develop at a high frequency among patients showing B type in YG test and patients presenting laterality in electroencephalography. Among the 49 right stroke patients, depressive state was observed in 10 cases (20.4%), while among the 43 left stroke patients, depressive state was seen in 10 cases (23.2%) with the incidence of depressive state showing no difference by hemisphere stroke. Study of the clinical characteristics of depressive state by hemisphere stroke with the use of symptom items of Zung scale and Hamilton scale showed that patients in depressive state with right hemisphere stroke had high values in symptom items considered close to the essence of endogenous depression such as depressed mood, suicide, diurnal variation, loss of weight, and paranoid symptoms, while patients in depressive state with left hemisphere stroke had high values in symptom items having a nuance of so-called neurotic depression such as psychic anxiety, hypochondriasis, and fatigue. Comparison with endogenous depression patients indicated that right stroke patients rather than left stroke patients showed a clinical picture suggestive of endogenous depression. Antidepressant was effective in 71.4% of the cases, but no difference in effectiveness could be observed by hemisphere stroke. In stroke patients in the chronic stage the incidence of clinical depressive state was higher than 20%, and involved in its onset were not only brain organ lesions but also dispositional, social, and somatic factors and integration dysfunction in the emotional activity of the left and right hemisphere functions. As for the clinical picture, a picture considered close to endogenous depression was observed in right stroke patients, while that considered close to so-called neurotic depression was seen in left stroke patients. The therapeutic effect of antidepressant was almost equivalent to that for endogenous depression.
对处于慢性期的中风患者的抑郁状态进行了一项临床研究。本研究中有118名中风患者,其中25名患者(21.2%)符合《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第三版修订版(DSM-III-R)中重度抑郁综合征的诊断标准。关于性格、社会和躯体因素,观察到在中风发病前有精神障碍病史的患者、居住在郊区的患者、从事家务和农业工作的患者以及有频繁身体疾病史的患者中,抑郁状态的发生频率较高。在YG测试中表现为B型的患者和脑电图显示有偏侧性的患者中,抑郁状态的发生频率也较高。在49例右侧中风患者中,有10例(20.4%)出现抑郁状态,而在43例左侧中风患者中,有10例(23.2%)出现抑郁状态,抑郁状态的发生率在不同半球中风患者中无差异。使用Zung量表和汉密尔顿量表的症状项目对不同半球中风患者的抑郁状态临床特征进行研究发现,右侧半球中风的抑郁状态患者在诸如情绪低落、自杀、昼夜变化、体重减轻和偏执症状等被认为接近内源性抑郁本质的症状项目上得分较高,而左侧半球中风的抑郁状态患者在具有所谓神经症性抑郁细微差别的症状项目上得分较高,如精神焦虑、疑病症和疲劳。与内源性抑郁患者比较表明,右侧中风患者比左侧中风患者表现出更提示内源性抑郁的临床症状。抗抑郁药在71.4%的病例中有效,但不同半球中风患者在疗效上无差异。在慢性期中风患者中,临床抑郁状态的发生率高于20%,其发病不仅涉及脑器质性病变,还涉及性格、社会和躯体因素以及左右半球功能情感活动的整合功能障碍。至于临床症状,右侧中风患者表现出接近内源性抑郁的症状,而左侧中风患者表现出接近所谓神经症性抑郁的症状。抗抑郁药的治疗效果与内源性抑郁的治疗效果几乎相当。