Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, MossRehab at Elkins Park/Albert Einstein Medical Center, 60 Township Line Rd, Elkins Park, PA 19027, USA.
PM R. 2012 Feb;4(2):129-40. doi: 10.1016/j.pmrj.2011.06.003.
Headache is one of the most common physical symptoms after traumatic brain injury (TBI). The specific goals of this review include (1) determination of effective interventions for post-traumatic headache (PTHA), (2) development of treatment recommendations, (3) identification of gaps in the current medical literature regarding PTHA treatment, and (4) suggestions for future directions in research to improve outcome for persons with PTHA.
Peer-reviewed studies in PubMed, CINAHL, PsycINFO, ProQuest, Web of Science, and Google Scholar: (1) including adult and child samples with mild, moderate, or severe TBI, whiplash, and postconcussion syndrome; (2) with clearly described interventions; (3) with headache treatment as a primary or secondary outcome; (4) published since 1985; and (5) written in English.
Abstracts from 812 articles from the above searches were reviewed. All research types that studied the treatment of headache after TBI were included, and 64 of the 812 articles appeared to meet the inclusion criteria.
The 64 articles were reviewed in full and data were extracted; 36 met all criteria for inclusion. The final 36 articles were rated according to the American Academy of Neurology criteria for classifying therapeutic studies.
No class I studies and only one class II study for the management of PTHA were identified. One class I and one class II study for whiplash-associated disorder with headache as an outcome were identified. Twelve studies met criteria for class III.
No strong evidence from clinical trials is available to direct the treatment of PTHA. Some guidelines are offered for PTHA management based on primary headache categories and treatments. It is essential that well-designed clinical studies be conducted to inform clinicians on the management and prevention of PTHA chronicity.
头痛是颅脑损伤(TBI)后最常见的躯体症状之一。本次综述的具体目标包括:(1)确定创伤后头痛(PTHA)的有效干预措施;(2)制定治疗建议;(3)明确当前关于 PTHA 治疗的医学文献中的空白;(4)为改善 PTHA 患者的预后提供未来研究方向的建议。
在 PubMed、CINAHL、PsycINFO、ProQuest、Web of Science 和 Google Scholar 中检索同行评审的研究:(1)纳入轻度、中度或重度 TBI、挥鞭样损伤和脑震荡后综合征的成人和儿童样本;(2)干预措施描述明确;(3)以头痛治疗为主要或次要结局;(4)自 1985 年以来发表;(5)用英文撰写。
综述了上述搜索中 812 篇文章的摘要。纳入了所有研究类型,这些研究都针对 TBI 后头痛的治疗,其中 64 篇文章似乎符合纳入标准。
对这 64 篇文章进行了全面审查并提取了数据,其中 36 篇符合所有纳入标准。最终的 36 篇文章根据美国神经病学学会的治疗研究分类标准进行了评分。
未发现 I 类研究,只有一项 II 类研究针对 PTHA 的管理。有一项 I 类和一项 II 类研究针对伴有头痛的挥鞭样损伤。有 12 项研究符合 III 类标准。
没有来自临床试验的有力证据可以指导 PTHA 的治疗。根据原发性头痛类别和治疗方法,为 PTHA 管理提供了一些指南。开展精心设计的临床试验对于告知临床医生 PTHA 的管理和预防慢性化至关重要。