Regueras De Lorenzo G, Santos Rodríguez P M, Villa Bajo L, Pérez Guirado A, Arbesú Fernández E, Barreiro Hurlé L, Nicieza García M
Departamento de Pediatría, Centro de Salud de Tineo, Asturias, España.
An Pediatr (Barc). 2012 Sep;77(3):193-9. doi: 10.1016/j.anpedi.2012.01.012. Epub 2012 Mar 2.
Streptococcus pyogenes is the most frequent bacterial cause of acute tonsillopharyngitis. The validity of the rapid antigen test was analysed for its diagnosis in a Paediatric Primary Care setting. The clinical profile with better diagnostic yield was also identified. The unnecessary use of antibiotics was quantified when the rapid antigen test or only the clinical diagnosis was used. The sensitivity of the assay to penicillin, erythromycin and clindamycin was also determined.
Cross-sectional study was conducted on children between 2 to 14 years with acute tonsillitis and/or pharyngitis seen in five Primary Care Centres, from January 2008 to May 2010. After a clinical diagnosis, two swabs were taken for pharyngotonsillar smears: the first was used for a rapid antigen test, and the second one for a culture and a study of antibiotic sensitivity, with its analysis being blind to the rapid test result. A total sample of 546 consecutive was envisaged and with consecutive sampling.
A total 192 patients were included. The prevalence of Streptococcus pyogenes was 38.7% (95% CI: 31.4-45.7). Odynophagia and scarlatiniform rash were most likely with positive cultures, the Streptococcus pyogenes was sensitive to penicillin in 100%, to erythromycin in 97.3% and to clindamycin in 86.3%. The specificity of the rapid antigen test was 91.5% and with a Negative Predictive Value of 91.5%. About half (49.2%) of those who would have receive antibiotics for clinical suspicion would have been treated unnecessarily, with this decreasing to at least in 29.5% when using the rapid antigen test.
The rapid antigen test can lead to a better use of antibiotics. Its use in Paediatric Primary Health Care could be useful when, as when the result is negative, there would be no need to confirm by a culture, in those Health Centres with difficult access to laboratory.
化脓性链球菌是急性扁桃体咽炎最常见的细菌病因。分析了快速抗原检测在儿科初级保健环境中用于诊断的有效性。还确定了诊断率更高的临床特征。当使用快速抗原检测或仅进行临床诊断时,对不必要使用抗生素的情况进行了量化。还测定了该检测对青霉素、红霉素和克林霉素的敏感性。
对2008年1月至2010年5月在五个初级保健中心就诊的2至14岁患有急性扁桃体炎和/或咽炎的儿童进行了横断面研究。在进行临床诊断后,采集两份咽扁桃体涂片拭子:第一份用于快速抗原检测,第二份用于培养和抗生素敏感性研究,其分析对快速检测结果保密。设想并采用连续抽样的方式共采集546例样本。
共纳入192例患者。化脓性链球菌的患病率为38.7%(95%可信区间:31.4 - 45.7)。吞咽痛和猩红热样皮疹在培养阳性时最为常见,化脓性链球菌对青霉素的敏感性为100%,对红霉素的敏感性为97.3%,对克林霉素的敏感性为86.3%。快速抗原检测的特异性为91.5%,阴性预测值为91.5%。因临床怀疑而接受抗生素治疗的患者中约一半(49.2%)会接受不必要的治疗,而使用快速抗原检测时,这一比例至少降至29.5%。
快速抗原检测可更好地使用抗生素。在儿科初级卫生保健中使用该检测可能会很有用,例如当结果为阴性时,在那些难以获得实验室检测的卫生中心无需通过培养进行确认。