The Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Bronx, NY, USA.
Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2012 Mar 1;37(5):414-7. doi: 10.1097/BRS.0b013e3182451540.
We prospectively evaluated the costs/frequency of explanted instrumentation (devices implanted but removed prior to closure) for all single-level anterior diskectomy (1-ADF) procedures performed in 2010 at a single institution before and after surgeon education.
To determine whether surgeon education would reduce the costs/frequency of explantation for 1-ADF.
In 2009, we reported that the cost of explanted devices was 9.2% of the cost of implanted devices.
The costs/frequencies of explantation for 1-ADF performed in 2010 at the same institution by the same surgeons were analyzed before and after surgeon education. From January through April, surgeons were unaware of concerns regarding explantation. At the end of April 2010, spinal surgeons were educated about explantation costs/frequency at 2 meetings. Explantation costs/frequencies for the first 4 months of 2010 were compared with those for the last 8 months as well as with the results from 2009.
Prior to surgeon education, instrumentation was explanted in 45.5% of the cases, whereas after education explantation occurred in 16% of the cases. The explantation rate (the number of explanted devices as a percentage of implanted devices) was lower after education for screws (12.5% vs. 7.7%), plates (9.4% vs. 0%), and allograft spacers (7.1% vs. 2.9%), and lower than for rates from 2009. In 2010, the overall cost of explanted devices as a percentage of implanted devices was also lower after surgeon education (5.8%) than before surgeon education in 2010 (20.0%) or 2009 (9.2%).
The frequency and cost of explanted instrumentation used to perform 1-ADF were reduced through surgeon education.
我们前瞻性地评估了 2010 年在一家机构进行的所有单节段前路椎间盘切除术(1-ADF)手术中植入但在关闭前取出的器械(植入但取出的器械)的成本/频率,在手术医生接受教育前后进行了比较。
确定手术医生教育是否会降低 1-ADF 器械的取出率/频率。
2009 年,我们报告称,取出器械的成本占植入器械成本的 9.2%。
分析了 2010 年在同一机构由同一手术医生进行的 1-ADF 手术中在手术医生接受教育前后的取出率/频率。1 月至 4 月,手术医生并不知道有关取出的问题。2010 年 4 月底,脊柱外科医生在 2 次会议上接受了有关取出成本/频率的教育。将 2010 年前 4 个月的取出率/频率与后 8 个月的取出率/频率以及 2009 年的结果进行了比较。
在手术医生接受教育之前,45.5%的病例中取出了器械,而在教育之后,16%的病例中取出了器械。接受教育后,螺钉(12.5%比 7.7%)、钢板(9.4%比 0%)和同种异体骨移植间隔物(7.1%比 2.9%)的取出率(取出的器械数占植入的器械数的百分比)较低,且低于 2009 年的取出率。2010 年,与 2010 年手术医生接受教育前(20.0%)或 2009 年(9.2%)相比,取出的器械的总体成本占植入的器械的成本的百分比也较低。
通过手术医生教育,降低了单节段前路椎间盘切除术(1-ADF)中使用的取出器械的频率和成本。