Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Helsinki University Central Hospital, Finland.
Hum Reprod. 2012 Jun;27(6):1628-36. doi: 10.1093/humrep/des103. Epub 2012 Mar 14.
Pharmaceutical thrombosis prophylaxis (PTP) with low-molecular-weight heparin (LMWH) is highly effective in preventing venous thromboembolic events (VTEs) and fatal pulmonary embolism. Important risk factors for VTEs are surgery and immobilization, along with malignancy. Many studies involving gynaecological malignancies show no increased risk for bleeding complications with PTP. Little is known about the PTP-associated risk for bleeding complications with hysterectomy for benign disease, or about current VTE incidence in the less-invasive hysterectomy methods.
Our observational prospective national 1-year cohort from 1 January to 31 December 2006 in 53 hospitals represented 79.4% (5297 of 6645) of hysterectomies performed for benign cause in Finland in 2006. We evaluated PTP use and VTE incidence. Operative and post-operative bleeding complications were analysed with logistic regression adjusted for confounders: age, BMI, experience of the gynaecological surgeon, hospital type, indication for hysterectomy, uterine weight, operative haemorrhage, concomitant surgery, adhesiolysis and antibiotic prophylaxis.
Hysterectomies were performed by three main approaches: 2345 vaginal hysterectomies (VHs, 44%), of which 1433 were for uterine prolapse and 912 for other indications, 1679 laparoscopic hysterectomies (LHs, 32%) and 1255 abdominal hysterectomies (AHs, 24%). PTP was given to 64.8% of patients (3420 of 5279) and was identified as LMWH in 3313 patients (97%); 107 left unidentified. By type of hysterectomy, PTP was given in VH for uterine prolapse to 73.2% of patients, VH for other indication to 51.6%, in LH to 59.4% and in AH to 71.9%. For all hysterectomies analysed together, PTP doubled the odds for post-operative haemorrhage or haematoma. By type of hysterectomy, PTP associated with post-operative haemorrhage or haematoma in VH for prolapse [2.7% of PTP given, versus 0.8% of no PTP; odds ratio (OR): 4.82, 95% confidence interval (CI): 1.38-16.83]; and in AH (3.1% versus 1.4%; OR: 2.87, 95% CI: 1.03-7.98), and in AH also with post-operative transfusion (3.1% versus 1.4%; OR: 3.34, 95% CI: 1.41-7.88). For LH and VH for indications other than prolapse, the effect of PTP on post-operative haemorrhage was non-significant. For VH, the risk for post-operative haemorrhage fell with age. Operative mean haemorrhage with all hysterectomy types, and operative bleeding complications in AH and VH also fell with age. Obesity increased haemorrhage and operative bleeding complications for LH and VH, whereas post-operative bleeding complications were less for the obese in AH. VTEs were 6 of 5279 (0.1%): two PEs each occurred after AH and VH, and two deep venous thromboses after LH.
With a relatively wide PTP coverage (64.8%), VTEs were rare (0.1%). All affected had received PTP. Analysis of efficacy, meaning interpretation of how many VTEs or deaths were prevented, cannot be done from our observational study but related to safety in hysterectomy for benign disease, PTP associated with post-operative bleeding complications with AH and with VH for prolapse.
ClinicalTrials.gov protocol (NCT00744172).
低分子肝素(LMWH)的药物血栓预防(PTP)在预防静脉血栓栓塞事件(VTE)和致命性肺栓塞方面非常有效。VTE 的重要危险因素包括手术和固定,以及恶性肿瘤。许多涉及妇科恶性肿瘤的研究表明,PTP 不会增加出血并发症的风险。对于良性疾病子宫切除术的 PTP 相关出血并发症风险以及较少侵入性子宫切除术方法的当前 VTE 发生率知之甚少。
我们的观察性前瞻性全国性 1 年队列研究于 2006 年 1 月 1 日至 12 月 31 日进行,涉及芬兰 53 家医院,代表了芬兰 2006 年良性病因子宫切除术的 79.4%(5297/6645)。我们评估了 PTP 的使用和 VTE 的发生率。通过逻辑回归分析调整混杂因素,分析手术和术后出血并发症:年龄、BMI、妇科外科医生的经验、医院类型、子宫切除术的指征、子宫重量、手术出血、同时手术、粘连松解术和抗生素预防。
子宫切除术主要通过三种方法进行:2345 例阴道子宫切除术(VH,44%),其中 1433 例为子宫脱垂,912 例为其他指征,1679 例腹腔镜子宫切除术(LH,32%)和 1255 例腹式子宫切除术(AH,24%)。64.8%的患者(5279 例中的 3420 例)接受了 PTP,其中 3313 例(97%)被确定为 LMWH;107 例未识别。按子宫切除术类型,VH 治疗子宫脱垂的患者中 73.2%接受了 PTP,VH 治疗其他指征的患者中 51.6%接受了 PTP,LH 中 59.4%接受了 PTP,AH 中 71.9%接受了 PTP。对于所有子宫切除术综合分析,PTP 使术后出血或血肿的可能性增加了一倍。按子宫切除术类型,PTP 与 VH 治疗脱垂的术后出血或血肿相关(2.7%的 PTP 患者,0.8%的无 PTP 患者;比值比[OR]:4.82,95%置信区间[CI]:1.38-16.83);与 AH(3.1%与 1.4%;OR:2.87,95%CI:1.03-7.98)相关,与 AH 也与术后输血相关(3.1%与 1.4%;OR:3.34,95%CI:1.41-7.88)。对于脱垂以外的其他指征的 LH 和 VH,PTP 对术后出血的影响无统计学意义。对于 VH,随着年龄的增长,术后出血的风险降低。所有子宫切除术类型的手术平均出血量,以及 AH 和 VH 的手术出血并发症也随年龄下降。肥胖增加了 LH 和 VH 的出血和手术出血并发症,而肥胖患者的术后出血并发症较少。VTE 为 5279 例中的 6 例(0.1%):AH 和 VH 各发生 2 例肺栓塞,LH 各发生 2 例深静脉血栓形成。
相对较广的 PTP 覆盖率(64.8%),VTE 罕见(0.1%)。所有受影响的患者都接受了 PTP。从我们的观察性研究中无法对疗效进行分析,即无法解释有多少 VTE 或死亡得到了预防,而只能与良性疾病子宫切除术的安全性相关,PTP 与 AH 的术后出血并发症相关,与脱垂的 VH 相关。
ClinicalTrials.gov 方案(NCT00744172)。