Paoletti Oscar A, Fraire María E, Sanchez-Vallecillo María V, Zernotti Mauro, Olmos Manuel E, Zernotti Mario E
Servicio de Otorrinolaringología, Sanatorio Allende, Córdoba Capital, Provincia de Córdoba, Argentina.
Acta Otorrinolaringol Esp. 2012 May-Jun;63(3):200-5. doi: 10.1016/j.otorri.2011.12.003. Epub 2012 Mar 19.
Muscle tension dysphonia (MTD) is a voice disorder in the absence of current organic laryngeal pathology, without obvious psychogenic or neurological aetiology. The laryngeal features of MTD include a posterior glottal gap and supraglottic hyperfunctional activities; however, it remains unclear if these features are specific to MTD. This report aims to compare the laryngeal features in telemarketer patients with MTD versus non-dysphonic control subjects.
We reported on an observational, analytic and transversal study. Fiberoptic nasal endoscopy was performed on 57 patients (28 telemarketers with MTD and 29 control subjects). These random-sequence videotapes were independently rated by an expert laryngologist according to the modified Morrison and Rammage classification. In addition, a questionnaire about vocal symptoms and other details was completed.
The posterior glottal gap was the most common feature in telemarketers with MTD, while incomplete glottal gap was observed more frequently in non-dysphonic patients. More than 70% of the videotapes were rated as pathologic. There was no statistical difference in the prevalence of normal features or bowing glottal gap between patients and control subjects. Anterior-posterior supraglottic contraction was more frequent in the control group. The major symptoms found were: voice gets tired quickly, increased vocal effort and neck tension.
The heterogeneity in the laryngeal features in telemarketers with MTD seen under fibroscopy and their presence among the non-dysphonic population suggest that they cannot determine by themselves the diagnosis of MTD.
肌肉紧张性发声障碍(MTD)是一种在当前不存在器质性喉部病变、无明显心理性或神经性病因的情况下出现的嗓音障碍。MTD的喉部特征包括声门后间隙和声门上高功能性活动;然而,这些特征是否为MTD所特有仍不清楚。本报告旨在比较电话推销员中患有MTD的患者与无嗓音障碍的对照受试者的喉部特征。
我们报告了一项观察性、分析性横断面研究。对57名患者(28名患有MTD的电话推销员和29名对照受试者)进行了纤维鼻内镜检查。这些随机序列的录像带由一名专业喉科医生根据改良的莫里森和拉马奇分类法进行独立评分。此外,还完成了一份关于嗓音症状和其他细节的问卷。
声门后间隙是患有MTD的电话推销员中最常见的特征,而在无嗓音障碍的患者中更常观察到声门间隙不完全。超过70%的录像带被评为病理性。患者和对照受试者之间正常特征或声门间隙弓形的患病率没有统计学差异。对照组中前后声门上收缩更频繁。发现的主要症状有:嗓音很快疲劳、发声用力增加和颈部紧张。
纤维镜检查所见患有MTD的电话推销员喉部特征的异质性以及它们在无嗓音障碍人群中的存在表明,这些特征本身不能确定MTD的诊断。