Nguyen Duong Duy, Kenny Dianna T, Tran Ninh Duy, Livesey Jonathan R
Department of Otolaryngology, Thai Nguyen General Central Hospital, Thai Nguyen city, Vietnam.
J Voice. 2009 Mar;23(2):195-208. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2007.09.003. Epub 2008 Jan 22.
There has been no published research on muscle tension dysphonia (MTD) in speakers who use a tonal language. Using a sample of 47 Northern Vietnamese female primary school teachers with MTD, we aimed to discover whether professional voice users of tonal languages presented with the same symptoms of MTD as speakers of nontonal languages and whether they presented with additional symptoms as a result of speaking a tonal language. The vocal characteristics were assessed by use of a questionnaire and expert perceptual evaluation. Laryngeal features were assessed by photolaryngoscopy. The results showed that MTD was associated with a larger number of vocal symptoms than previously reported. However, the participants did not have the same vocal symptoms reported in English speakers, for example, hard glottal attack, pitch breaks, unusual speech rate, and glottal fry. Factor analysis of the vocal symptoms revealed three factors: "vocal fatigue/hyperfunction," "physical discomfort," and "voice quality," all of which demonstrated high reliability. The major laryngeal characteristic was a glottal gap. The glottal shapes observed included: 44.7% had an incomplete closure, 29.8% a posterior gap, 12.8% an hourglass-shaped gap, 8.5% a spindle-shaped gap, and 4.3% had complete glottal closure. The findings implied a potential contribution of linguistic-specific factors and teaching-related factors to the presentation of this voice disorder in this group of teachers.
对于使用声调语言的人群中肌肉紧张性发音障碍(MTD),目前尚无已发表的研究。我们以47名患有MTD的越南北部女性小学教师为样本,旨在探究使用声调语言的职业用嗓者是否表现出与使用非声调语言者相同的MTD症状,以及他们是否因讲声调语言而出现额外症状。通过问卷调查和专家感知评估来评定嗓音特征。通过喉镜检查评估喉部特征。结果显示,MTD相关的嗓音症状比之前报道的更多。然而,这些参与者并没有出现英语使用者中所报道的相同嗓音症状,例如硬起声、音高突变、异常语速和喉音。对嗓音症状的因子分析揭示出三个因子:“嗓音疲劳/功能亢进”、“身体不适”和“嗓音质量”,所有这些因子都显示出高可靠性。主要的喉部特征是声门间隙。观察到的声门形态包括:44.7%为不完全闭合,29.8%为后部间隙,12.8%为沙漏形间隙,8.5%为纺锤形间隙,4.3%为声门完全闭合。这些发现表明特定语言因素和教学相关因素可能对这群教师中这种嗓音障碍的表现有影响。