University of Parma, Italy.
J Cogn Neurosci. 2012 Jul;24(7):1584-95. doi: 10.1162/jocn_a_00230. Epub 2012 Mar 27.
Neuroscientists and philosophers, among others, have long questioned the contribution of bodily experience to the constitution of self-consciousness. Contemporary research answers this question by focusing on the notions of sense of agency and/or sense of ownership. Recently, however, it has been proposed that the bodily self might also be rooted in bodily motor experience, that is, in the experience of oneself as instantiating a bodily structure that enables a specific range of actions. In the current fMRI study, we tested this hypothesis by making participants undergo a hand laterality judgment task, which is known to be solved by simulating a motor rotation of one's own hand. The stimulus to be judged was either the participant's own hand or the hand of a stranger. We used this task to investigate whether mental rotation of pictures depicting one's own hands leads to a different activation of the sensorimotor areas as compared with the mental rotation of pictures depicting another's hand. We revealed a neural network for the general representation of the bodily self encompassing the SMA and pre-SMA, the anterior insula, and the occipital cortex, bilaterally. Crucially, the representation of one's own dominant hand turned out to be primarily confined to the left premotor cortex. Our data seem to support the existence of a sense of bodily self encased within the sensorimotor system. We propose that such a sensorimotor representation of the bodily self might help us to differentiate our own body from that of others.
神经科学家和哲学家等长期以来一直在质疑身体经验对自我意识构成的贡献。当代研究通过关注代理感和/或拥有感的概念来回答这个问题。然而,最近有人提出,身体自我也可能根植于身体运动经验,即体验自己作为体现身体结构的主体,这种结构使身体能够执行特定范围的动作。在当前的 fMRI 研究中,我们通过让参与者进行手偏向性判断任务来检验这一假设,该任务已知通过模拟自己的手的运动旋转来解决。要判断的刺激是参与者自己的手或陌生人的手。我们使用这个任务来研究在描述自己的手的图片的心理旋转是否会导致与描述另一只手的图片的心理旋转相比,感觉运动区域的不同激活。我们揭示了一个用于一般身体自我表示的神经网络,包括 SMA 和前 SMA、前岛叶和双侧枕叶皮层。至关重要的是,自己的优势手的表示主要局限于左侧运动前皮层。我们的数据似乎支持存在一种被包裹在感觉运动系统内的身体自我意识。我们提出,这种身体自我的感觉运动表示可能有助于我们将自己的身体与他人的身体区分开来。