Orth Michael, Schwenke Carsten
Department of Neurology, University of Ulm, Ulm, Germany and Independent Statistical Consultant, SCOSSiS, Germany.
PLoS Curr. 2011 Jul 29;3:RRN1258. doi: 10.1371/currents.RRN1258.
In Huntington disease, the accurate determination of age-at-onset is critical to identify modifiers and therapies that aim to delay it.
Retrospective data from the European Huntington's Disease Network's REGISTRY and PREDICT-HD, a longitudinal study in prodromal huntingtin gene expansion mutation carriers. Data (age, gender, CAG repeat length, parent affected, and Unified Huntington's Disease Rating Scale motor score, total functional capacity) from at least three visits in 423 REGISTRY and 124 PREDICT-HD participants were included. Data based extrapolations of individual age-at-onset using generalized linear mixed models based on individual slopes of motor score or total functional capacity, and predictions using the Langbehn, or Ranen formula, were compared with clinicians' estimates.
Concordance was best for the observed age-at-onset in PREDICT-HD and the calculated onset using the PREDICT-HD UHDRS longitudinal motor scores. This was superior to the REGISTRY data. For total functional capacity, the investigator's estimate was 4 years before the data derived age-at-onset. The concordance of predictions of probability of age-at-onset is better with the observed age-at-onset in the PREDICT-HD data (difference in 25%tile -5 to 10 years) than the REGISTRY data (±20 years).
Estimating or predicting age-at-onset in Huntington disease may be inaccurate. It can be useful to 1) add in the manifest population motor score regression derived age-at-onset as additional motor onset and 2) add total functional capacity regression derived age-at-onset for the onset of functional impact of Huntington disease when patients are in mid- to late-stage.
在亨廷顿舞蹈症中,准确确定发病年龄对于识别旨在延缓发病的调节因素和治疗方法至关重要。
来自欧洲亨廷顿舞蹈症网络注册库和PREDICT-HD的回顾性数据,PREDICT-HD是一项针对前驱期亨廷顿基因扩展突变携带者的纵向研究。纳入了423名注册库参与者和124名PREDICT-HD参与者至少三次访视的数据(年龄、性别、CAG重复长度、父母是否患病以及统一亨廷顿舞蹈症评定量表运动评分、总功能能力)。使用基于运动评分或总功能能力个体斜率的广义线性混合模型对个体发病年龄进行数据外推,并与临床医生的估计值进行比较,同时使用Langbehn或Ranen公式进行预测。
PREDICT-HD中观察到的发病年龄与使用PREDICT-HD统一亨廷顿舞蹈症评定量表纵向运动评分计算出的发病年龄一致性最佳。这优于注册库数据。对于总功能能力,研究者的估计比数据得出的发病年龄早4年。PREDICT-HD数据中发病年龄概率预测与观察到的发病年龄的一致性(第25百分位数差异为-5至10年)优于注册库数据(±20年)。
估计或预测亨廷顿舞蹈症的发病年龄可能不准确。对于以下情况可能有用:1)将显性人群运动评分回归得出的发病年龄作为额外的运动发病年龄纳入;2)在患者处于中晚期时,将总功能能力回归得出的发病年龄纳入,以了解亨廷顿舞蹈症功能影响的发病情况。