Taussig Cancer Institute, Case Western Reserve University, Lerner School of Medicine, Cleveland Clinic, Palliative Medicine and Supportive Oncology Services, Cleveland, OH 44195, USA.
Expert Opin Drug Discov. 2012 Feb;7(2):165-78. doi: 10.1517/17460441.2012.648611. Epub 2012 Jan 4.
Single opioid analgesics are modestly effective in reducing pain but have a narrow therapeutic index and frequently produce intolerable side effects. Adjuvant analgesics are often used to improve the opioid therapeutic index. Basic science research has accumulated evidence that opioid combinations in animal models and in vitro have potential to improve the therapeutic index of opioids and/or prevent opioid tolerance.
Opioid receptor pharmacology is reviewed including receptor genetics and downstream signaling. Receptor functional selectivity and ligand biased responses are discussed in relationship to opioid pharmacodynamics, signal modulation and synergy. The accumulated bench research over the past decade, in particular, provides a rationale for considering clinical trials of opioid combinations. These combinations include both selective agonist-agonist or agonist-antagonist pairs which are reviewed.
The use of opioid antagonists (naloxone and naltrexone), oxycodone, fentanyl and methadone with morphine improves analgesia in animal models and blunts physical dependence and conditioned place preference (a marker for psychological dependence). Sequential or simultaneous dosing schedules, dose levels or ratios need to be explored further. Pain phenotype may be an important factor predicting responses to combinations such that trial design will need to take this into account. Side effects will need to be monitored closely as little is known about the influence of opioid combinations on side effects.
单一阿片类镇痛药在减轻疼痛方面的效果较为温和,但治疗指数较窄,且常产生无法耐受的副作用。辅助镇痛药常被用于提高阿片类药物的治疗指数。基础科学研究已经积累了证据,表明在动物模型和体外,阿片类药物联合使用具有提高阿片类药物治疗指数和/或预防阿片类药物耐受的潜力。
本文回顾了阿片受体药理学,包括受体遗传学和下游信号转导。讨论了受体功能选择性和配体偏向反应与阿片类药物药效学、信号调节和协同作用的关系。过去十年积累的基础研究为考虑阿片类药物联合治疗的临床试验提供了依据。这些联合用药包括选择性激动剂-激动剂或激动剂-拮抗剂对,对其进行了综述。
阿片类拮抗剂(纳洛酮和纳曲酮)、羟考酮、芬太尼和美沙酮与吗啡联合使用可改善动物模型中的镇痛效果,并减轻身体依赖和条件性位置偏好(心理依赖的标志)。需要进一步探索序贯或同时给药方案、剂量水平或比例。疼痛表型可能是预测联合用药反应的一个重要因素,因此试验设计需要考虑到这一点。需要密切监测副作用,因为对阿片类药物联合用药对副作用的影响知之甚少。