Webber Tracy A, Webber Anthony E, Matzkin Elizabeth
Tufts University School of Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Orthopedics. 2012 Apr;35(4):e514-9. doi: 10.3928/01477447-20120327-26.
Viscosupplementation, hyaluronic acid treatment, is an ancillary method for treating patients with symptomatic stage I or II osteoarthritis. Previous studies reported that local reactions occurred more frequently in patients receiving >1 course of treatment compared with patients receiving their first course of treatment. One (2%) of 42 first series patients and 4 (21%) of 19 of repeated series patients had adverse reactions severe enough to seek unscheduled care.This study was performed to determine whether patients receiving >1 series of viscosupplementation had an increased adverse reaction rate. A retrospective chart review was performed on all patients who received >1 series of viscosupplementation during the study. A local adverse reaction was defined as acute swelling and pain in the knee, with no injury or trauma within 72 hours after hyaluronic acid injection.Twenty-eight knees received >1 series of viscosupplementation. The adverse reaction rate to second series injections was 1.28% (3.57% of knees). The adverse reaction rate to ≥3 series was 0.9% (6.67% of knees). This adverse reaction rate was significantly less than the 21% reported in previous studies for multiple series injections (z=-1.90; P<.05) and is not significantly different than the 2% rate of adverse reactions reported for first series injections. No significant difference existed in the adverse reaction rates between 2 series and ≥3 series of viscosupplementation.The current study suggests that the rate of adverse reaction was low at 1.28% of second series viscosupplementation.
粘弹性补充疗法,即透明质酸治疗,是治疗症状性I期或II期骨关节炎患者的辅助方法。先前的研究报告称,与接受首个疗程治疗的患者相比,接受超过1个疗程治疗的患者局部反应更频繁。42例首个疗程患者中有1例(2%),19例重复疗程患者中有4例(21%)出现严重不良反应,需要进行非计划护理。本研究旨在确定接受超过1个疗程粘弹性补充疗法的患者不良反应发生率是否增加。对研究期间接受超过1个疗程粘弹性补充疗法的所有患者进行了回顾性病历审查。局部不良反应定义为膝关节急性肿胀和疼痛,在透明质酸注射后72小时内无损伤或创伤。28个膝关节接受了超过1个疗程的粘弹性补充疗法。第二个疗程注射的不良反应发生率为1.28%(膝关节的3.57%)。≥3个疗程的不良反应发生率为0.9%(膝关节的6.67%)。该不良反应发生率显著低于先前研究中报道的多个疗程注射的21%(z=-1.90;P<.05),且与首个疗程注射报道的2%不良反应发生率无显著差异。2个疗程和≥3个疗程的粘弹性补充疗法之间的不良反应发生率没有显著差异。当前研究表明,第二个疗程粘弹性补充疗法的不良反应发生率较低,为1.28%。