Faculdade de Ciências do Desporto e Educação Física, Estádio Universitário Coimbra Pavilhão-III, Coimbra, Portugal.
Appl Physiol Nutr Metab. 2012 Jun;37(3):463-71. doi: 10.1139/h2012-027. Epub 2012 Apr 12.
The purpose of this study was to assess the agreement of lower-limb volume estimates based on anthropometry and dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) as a reference method in male rugby athletes. Predictive models using body mass and skinfolds were tested to improve the relative agreement between protocols (anthropometry, DXA). Rugby players (n = 41; 19.9 ± 2.2 years) volunteered for the study. Lower-limb total and fat-free volumes were estimated by anthropometry and also derived using DXA. Cross-validation between the anthropometry technique and DXA was then performed. Lower-limb volume estimates by anthropometry overestimated reference values and tended to be further from the reference values with the increase of scale. For the total sample, standard errors of measurement for volume estimates by anthropometry were 1.99 L and 1.34 L for total and fat-free volumes, respectively. Correlations with reference values were 0.81 for lower-limb volume and 0.90 for lower-limb fat-free volume. Correlations between estimated prediction equations and reference values showed higher correlations (r = 0.96 for lower-limb volume and r = 0.93 for lower-limb fat-free volume) compared with anthropometric estimates. Overall, the agreement of anthropometry method to quantify lower-limb volumes with DXA as a reference in young adult rugby players is acceptable and is a practical method when more expensive and complex techniques are not available. The consideration of body mass and lower-limb skinfolds increases the precision of lower-limb volume estimates using anthropometry in the young adult rugby players.
本研究旨在评估基于人体测量学和双能 X 射线吸收法(DXA)作为参考方法的下肢体积估计在男性橄榄球运动员中的一致性。使用体重和皮褶厚度的预测模型来提高协议之间的相对一致性(人体测量学、DXA)。橄榄球运动员(n=41;19.9±2.2 岁)自愿参加了这项研究。下肢总体积和去脂体积通过人体测量学进行估计,也通过 DXA 得出。然后对人体测量学技术和 DXA 之间的交叉验证进行了分析。人体测量学的下肢体积估计值高估了参考值,并且随着规模的增加,与参考值的差距进一步加大。对于整个样本,人体测量学体积估计的测量标准误差分别为总体积和去脂体积的 1.99 L 和 1.34 L。与参考值的相关性分别为下肢体积的 0.81 和下肢去脂体积的 0.90。与参考值的估计预测方程之间的相关性显示出更高的相关性(下肢体积的 r=0.96,下肢去脂体积的 r=0.93),与人体测量学估计相比。总的来说,在年轻的成年橄榄球运动员中,人体测量学方法与 DXA 作为参考来定量下肢体积的一致性是可以接受的,当没有更昂贵和复杂的技术时,它是一种实用的方法。考虑体重和下肢皮褶可以提高人体测量学在年轻成年橄榄球运动员中下肢体积估计的精度。