Zemski Adam J, Broad Elizabeth M, Slater Gary J
1 University of the Sunshine Coast.
2 US Olympic Committee.
Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab. 2018 Jan 1;28(1):90-99. doi: 10.1123/ijsnem.2017-0251. Epub 2018 Jan 24.
Body composition in elite rugby union athletes is routinely assessed using surface anthropometry, which can be utilized to provide estimates of absolute body composition using regression equations. This study aims to assess the ability of available skinfold equations to estimate body composition in elite rugby union athletes who have unique physique traits and divergent ethnicity. The development of sport-specific and ethnicity-sensitive equations was also pursued. Forty-three male international Australian rugby union athletes of Caucasian and Polynesian descent underwent surface anthropometry and dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) assessment. Body fat percent (BF%) was estimated using five previously developed equations and compared to DXA measures. Novel sport and ethnicity-sensitive prediction equations were developed using forward selection multiple regression analysis. Existing skinfold equations provided unsatisfactory estimates of BF% in elite rugby union athletes, with all equations demonstrating a 95% prediction interval in excess of 5%. The equations tended to underestimate BF% at low levels of adiposity, whilst overestimating BF% at higher levels of adiposity, regardless of ethnicity. The novel equations created explained a similar amount of variance to those previously developed (Caucasians 75%, Polynesians 90%). The use of skinfold equations, including the created equations, cannot be supported to estimate absolute body composition. Until a population-specific equation is established that can be validated to precisely estimate body composition, it is advocated to use a proven method, such as DXA, when absolute measures of lean and fat mass are desired, and raw anthropometry data routinely to derive an estimate of body composition change.
精英英式橄榄球运动员的身体成分通常采用体表人体测量法进行评估,该方法可利用回归方程来估算绝对身体成分。本研究旨在评估现有皮褶厚度方程对具有独特体型特征和不同种族的精英英式橄榄球运动员身体成分的估算能力。同时也致力于开发针对特定运动和种族敏感的方程。43名具有高加索和波利尼西亚血统的澳大利亚男性国际英式橄榄球运动员接受了体表人体测量和双能X线吸收法(DXA)评估。使用五个先前开发的方程估算体脂百分比(BF%),并与DXA测量结果进行比较。采用向前选择多元回归分析开发了新的针对运动和种族敏感的预测方程。现有皮褶厚度方程对精英英式橄榄球运动员BF%的估算结果不尽人意,所有方程的95%预测区间均超过5%。无论种族如何,这些方程在低肥胖水平时往往低估BF%,而在高肥胖水平时往往高估BF%。新创建的方程解释的方差量与先前开发的方程相似(高加索人为75%,波利尼西亚人为90%)。不支持使用皮褶厚度方程(包括新创建的方程)来估算绝对身体成分。在建立可验证以精确估算身体成分的特定人群方程之前,建议在需要精确测量瘦体重和脂肪量时使用经过验证的方法,如DXA,并常规使用原始人体测量数据来估算身体成分变化。