Department of Motricity Sciences and Rehabilitation, Liège University, Belgium.
Ann Phys Rehabil Med. 2012 May;55(4):229-40. doi: 10.1016/j.rehab.2012.03.004. Epub 2012 Apr 5.
The aim of this study was to assess the efficacy of gaseous cryotherapy following total knee arthroplasty (TKA) and to compare it to routinely used strategies for applying cold therapy.
Sixty-six patients undergoing primary unilateral TKA were randomized into three groups and received "gaseous cryotherapy (GC)", "cold pack" and "cryocuff" applications, respectively throughout the hospital stay. Primary outcomes (knee pain intensity, mobility and girth measurements) were recorded on preoperative day 1 as well as on postoperative day (POD) 7. Cutaneous temperature of the knee sides were also measured on POD7 just before and immediately after cold application.
Although skin temperature dropped to 14°C following GC versus 22 to 24°C for the other two applications (P<0,05), the three groups did not differ at POD7 regarding the three primary outcomes. No adverse effects were observed with any of the ways of application.
Gaseous cryotherapy was not more beneficial than routinely used strategies for applying cold therapy. Further studies with larger sample size and with a more frequent and closer gaseous cryotherapy applications are needed to confirm our results.
本研究旨在评估全膝关节置换术后(TKA)应用气态冷冻疗法的疗效,并将其与常规应用冷疗的策略进行比较。
66 例行单侧初次 TKA 的患者被随机分为三组,分别在住院期间接受“气态冷冻疗法(GC)”、“冷包”和“冷冻袖套”治疗。主要结局(膝关节疼痛强度、活动度和周长测量)在术前第 1 天和术后第 7 天(POD7)记录。在 POD7 时,在冷疗前和冷疗后立即测量膝关节两侧的皮肤温度。
尽管 GC 治疗后皮肤温度降至 14°C,而其他两种治疗方法降至 22 至 24°C(P<0.05),但三组在 POD7 时在三个主要结局方面无差异。任何应用方式均未观察到不良反应。
气态冷冻疗法并不优于常规应用冷疗的策略。需要进一步进行更大样本量的研究,并更频繁和更密切地应用气态冷冻疗法来验证我们的结果。