Faculty of Medicine, Université de Sherbrooke, Canada.
J Dent Educ. 2012 May;76(5):545-52.
Despite significant needs, people on social assistance are sometimes reluctant to consult dentists because of previous negative experience and communication barriers. They feel poorly understood by oral health professionals and sometimes complain of being stigmatized. It is thus important to know how dentists perceive poverty and this group of patients. The aim of this study was to understand how dentists perceive poverty and people on social assistance. To investigate this largely unexplored question, a qualitative study was conducted based on in-depth interviews with thirty-three dentists practicing in Montreal, Canada. Interviews were audiotaped and transcribed for qualitative analysis. The study revealed two perspectives on poverty: 1) the individualistic-deficit perspective and 2) the socio-lifecourse perspective. In the individualistic-deficit perspective, which predominated among these participants, dentists explained poverty by individual factors and emphasized individuals' negative attitudes toward work and lack of capabilities. Conversely, dentists with a socio-lifecourse perspective described poverty as a structural rather than an individual process. Acknowledging individuals' distress and powerlessness, these dentists expressed more empathy toward people on social assistance. The results suggest the individualistic-deficit perspective impedes the care relationship between dentists and poor patients as well as highlighting the need to better prepare dentists for addressing issues of poverty and social inequities in clinical practice.
尽管有巨大的需求,领取社会援助的人有时还是不愿意看牙医,因为之前有过负面经历和沟通障碍。他们觉得口腔保健专业人员不太理解他们,有时还抱怨受到歧视。因此,了解牙医如何看待贫困和这一群体的患者是很重要的。本研究旨在了解牙医如何看待贫困和领取社会援助的人。为了研究这个很大程度上尚未被探索的问题,进行了一项基于对在加拿大蒙特利尔执业的 33 名牙医的深入访谈的定性研究。访谈进行了录音,并转录为定性分析。研究揭示了两种贫困观:1)个人主义缺陷观和 2)社会生活历程观。在个人主义缺陷观中,牙医通过个人因素来解释贫困,并强调个人对工作的消极态度和缺乏能力。相反,具有社会生活历程观的牙医将贫困描述为一种结构性而非个人性的过程。这些牙医承认个人的困境和无力感,对领取社会援助的人表示出更多的同理心。研究结果表明,个人主义缺陷观阻碍了牙医和贫困患者之间的护理关系,并突出表明需要更好地为牙医在临床实践中解决贫困和社会不平等问题做好准备。