Dep. of Soil, Water, and Climate, Univ. of Minnesota, Lamberton 56152, USA.
J Environ Qual. 2012 May-Jun;41(3):901-10. doi: 10.2134/jeq2011.0451.
The most viable way to beneficially use animal manure on most farms is land application. Over the past few decades, repeated manure application has shown adverse effects on environmental quality due to phosphorus (P) runoff with rainwater, leading to eutrophication of aquatic ecosystems. Improved understanding of manure P chemistry may reduce this risk. In this research, 42 manure samples from seven animal species (beef and dairy cattle, swine, chicken, turkey, dairy goat, horse, and sheep) were sequentially fractionated with water, NaHCO₃, NaOH, and HCl. Inorganic (P(i)), organic (P(o)), enzymatic hydrolyzable (P(e); monoester-, DNA-, and phytate-like P), and nonhydrolyzable P were measured in each fraction. Total dry ash P (P(t)) was measured in all manures. Total fractionated P (P(ft)) and total P(i) (P(it)) showed a strong linear relationship with P(t). However, the ratios between P(ft)/P(t) and P(it)/P(t) varied from 59 to 117% and from 28 to 96%, respectively. Water and NaHCO₃ extracted most of the P(i) in manure from ruminant+horse, whereas in nonruminant species a large fraction of manure P was extracted in the HCl fraction. Manure P(e) summed over all fractions (P(et)) accounted for 41 to 69% of total P(0) and 4 to 29% of P(t). The hydrolyzable pool in the majority of the manures was dominated by phytate- and DNA-like P in water, monoester- and DNA-like P in NaHCO₃, and monoester- and phytate-like P in NaOH and HCl fractions. In conclusion, if one assumes that the P(et) and P(it) from the fractionation can become bioavailable, then from 34 to 100% of P(t) in animal manure would be bioavailable. This suggests the need for frequent monitoring of manure P for better manure management practices.
在大多数农场,最可行的利用动物粪便的方法是土地应用。在过去的几十年中,由于雨水导致磷(P)随径流流失,重复施粪肥对环境质量产生了不利影响,导致水生生态系统富营养化。更好地了解粪便 P 化学性质可能会降低这种风险。在这项研究中,从 7 种动物(牛和奶牛、猪、鸡、火鸡、奶牛山羊、马和绵羊)中采集了 42 个粪便样本,并用水、NaHCO₃、NaOH 和 HCl 进行顺序分级。在每个部分中都测量了无机(P(i))、有机(P(o))、酶水解(P(e);单酯、DNA 和植酸样 P)和不可水解 P。所有粪便均测量了总干灰分 P(P(t))。总分级 P(P(ft))和总 P(i)(P(it))与 P(t)呈强线性关系。但是,P(ft)/P(t)和 P(it)/P(t)的比值分别在 59%到 117%和 28%到 96%之间变化。水和 NaHCO₃从反刍动物+马的粪便中提取了大部分 P(i),而在非反刍动物中,大部分粪便 P 在 HCl 部分被提取。所有部分中 P(e)的总和(P(et))占总 P(0)的 41%至 69%和 P(t)的 4%至 29%。大多数粪便中的可水解池在水中以植酸和 DNA 样 P 为主,在 NaHCO₃中以单酯和 DNA 样 P 为主,在 NaOH 和 HCl 部分中以单酯和植酸样 P 为主。总之,如果假设分级中 P(et)和 P(it)可以变得具有生物利用性,则动物粪便中 P(t)的 34%到 100%可能具有生物利用性。这表明需要频繁监测粪便 P,以改善粪便管理实践。