Branum G D, Tyson G S, Branum M A, Meyers W C
Department of Surgery, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, North Carolina 27710.
Ann Surg. 1990 Dec;212(6):655-62. doi: 10.1097/00000658-199012000-00002.
Most recent reviews of pyogenic hepatic abscess emphasize percutaneous versus open surgical management and devote little time to studying the etiology or the clinical condition of the patient. In this study a detailed review was performed with a computerized analysis of multiple clinical parameters in 73 patients treated for pyogenic hepatic abscess during a 17-year period. The mean age of the patients was 55 years and 38 of them (52%) were male. The mortality rate was comparable for solitary (17%) and multiple (23%) abscesses. The likelihood of death was higher with antibiotic treatment alone (45%) or percutaneous treatment (25%) than with surgical treatment (9.5%). The primary determinant of outcome, however, was the underlying disease, i.e., malignancy or an immunocompromised patient, rather than solitary versus multiple abscesses. In addition the incidence of hepatic abscess seen at this center has doubled from the first half to the second half of the review, reflecting a population of more severely ill patients. It is apparent that in current clinical practice several methods of management are effective, and the choice of therapy should be determined by individualized selection. The principle of timely diagnosis and prompt institution of treatment appropriate to the specific patient remains the standard of care in this potentially grave disease.
近期关于化脓性肝脓肿的综述大多强调经皮治疗与开放手术治疗的对比,而很少花时间研究患者的病因或临床状况。在本研究中,我们对17年间接受治疗的73例化脓性肝脓肿患者的多个临床参数进行了详细的计算机分析回顾。患者的平均年龄为55岁,其中38例(52%)为男性。单发脓肿(17%)和多发脓肿(23%)的死亡率相当。单独使用抗生素治疗(45%)或经皮治疗(25%)的死亡可能性高于手术治疗(9.5%)。然而,结果的主要决定因素是基础疾病,即恶性肿瘤或免疫功能低下的患者,而非单发与多发脓肿。此外,在本研究期间,该中心所见肝脓肿的发病率从上半叶到下半叶增加了一倍,这反映出患者群体病情更严重。显然,在当前临床实践中,几种治疗方法都是有效的,治疗方法的选择应通过个体化选择来确定。对于这种潜在严重疾病,及时诊断并针对特定患者迅速采取适当治疗的原则仍然是治疗的标准。