Steger Florian, Görgl Andreas, Strube Wolfgang, Winckelmann Hans-J, Becker Thomas
Institute for History and Ethics of Medicine, University of Halle-Wittenberg, MLU Halle-Wittenberg, Germany.
Isr J Psychiatry Relat Sci. 2011;48(4):268-74.
This study aims to examine the practice of medical reporting in a totalitarian environment including systematic killing of people with mental illness in Nazi Germany. The historical analysis is based on patient documents and administrative files at today's District Hospital, Günzburg, as well as on patient documents of inventory R 179 of the branch office of the Federal Archives (Bundesarchiv) in Berlin/Lichterfelde. The paper describes four patient histories and attempts to reconstruct some aspects of patients' (mostly institutional) histories against the background of the Günzburg State Hospital serving as an assembly institution in the context of "Aktion T4." There is no certainty regarding the places of death of the four patients whose medical documentation is reported. In the patient records examined, the practice of medical description and reporting was characterized by a mixture of medical terminology, ideological diction and common language. The type of medical description and documentation used is an expression of stigmatization and discrimination of patients and of traumatizing institutional practice, and it reflects institutional violence. It is an ethical responsibility to reconstruct and commemorate the individual histories of mentally ill patients who were victims of the program of organized mass killings of people with mental illness. Places of death were camouflaged by the "Aktion T4," and there is uncertainty for many patients regarding where they were killed.
本研究旨在考察极权环境下的医学报告实践,其中包括纳粹德国对患有精神疾病者的系统性杀戮。历史分析基于当今贡茨堡地区医院的患者文件和行政档案,以及位于柏林利希特费尔德的联邦档案馆(德国联邦档案馆)分馆库存R 179中的患者文件。本文描述了四个患者的病史,并试图在贡茨堡州立医院作为 “T4行动” 背景下的集合机构的背景下,重构患者(大多为机构内患者)病史的一些方面。所报告的四名患者的死亡地点并不确定。在所检查的患者记录中,医学描述和报告的实践以医学术语、意识形态用语和日常语言的混合为特征。所使用的医学描述和记录类型是对患者的污名化和歧视以及创伤性机构实践的一种表现,它反映了机构暴力。重构和纪念精神疾病患者的个人病史是一项道德责任,这些患者是有组织地大规模杀害精神疾病患者计划的受害者。“T4行动” 掩盖了死亡地点,许多患者的死亡地点并不确定。