Barman Arunodaya, Jaafar Rogayah, Ismail Noorliza Mastura
Department of Medical Education, School of Medical Sciences.
Malays J Med Sci. 2006 Jan;13(1):63-7.
The implementation of problem-based learning started in 1969 and has spread since then throughout different parts of the world with variations in its implementation. In spite of its growth and advantages, there is continuing debate about its effectiveness over the conventional teaching learning methods. In the School of Dental Sciences (SDS), Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM), the Doctor of Dental Sciences (DDS) program follows a 5-year integrated curriculum. Basically the curriculum is problem-based and community oriented. This study was to explore the perception of DDS students about PBL sessions. This questionnaires-based cross sectional descriptive study were carried out on all the 110 students of the SDS who completed their second year of the course and participated in PBL sessions. Ninety five (86%) students responded to the questionnaires. Dental students found PBL session interesting and wanted to maintain PBL from the beginning of year 2 up to the end of year 3. Most students reported their participation in discussion during PBL sessions but the level of participation varied. Some of them worked hard to prepare themselves for discussion while others were relatively passive. PBL helped them with in-depth understanding of certain topics and link their basic science knowledge to clinical classes. They felt that guidance from subject specialists and well-prepared facilitators of the sessions were beneficial. The students believed that repetition of triggers from year to year discouraged their active search for learning issues. Majority of the students were undecided or disagreed about the availability of adequate learning resources Most of the students were undecided or disagreed about the availability of adequate learning resources for their self-study. Reviewing and renewing the PBL triggers, providing guidelines for searching for resource materials and briefing the students and facilitators about the philosophy and principles of PBL may make the PBL sessions more beneficial.
基于问题的学习始于1969年,从那时起已在世界各地传播,其实施方式各有不同。尽管它不断发展且具有优势,但关于其相对于传统教学方法的有效性仍存在持续的争论。在马来西亚理科大学牙科学院(SDS),牙科学博士(DDS)项目采用为期5年的综合课程。该课程基本上以问题为基础且面向社区。本研究旨在探索DDS学生对基于问题的学习(PBL)课程的看法。这项基于问卷的横断面描述性研究针对SDS所有完成课程第二年并参加PBL课程的110名学生展开。九十五名(86%)学生回复了问卷。牙科学生觉得PBL课程有趣,并希望从第二年开始到第三年末都保留PBL课程。大多数学生报告他们在PBL课程中参与了讨论,但参与程度各不相同。他们中的一些人努力为讨论做准备,而另一些人则相对被动。PBL帮助他们深入理解某些主题,并将基础科学知识与临床课程联系起来。他们认为学科专家和准备充分的课程引导者的指导是有益的。学生们认为每年重复使用问题情境会阻碍他们积极寻找学习问题。大多数学生对于是否有足够的学习资源用于自学持不确定或不同意的态度。审查和更新PBL问题情境、提供搜索参考资料的指南以及向学生和引导者介绍PBL的理念和原则可能会使PBL课程更有益。